I saw the Cthulhu image and it reminded me of the stories my son would tell me about the Kraken. (Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kraken for reference)
I was at the liquor store a few years back and saw this bottle of Kraken Rum:
https://www.krakenrum.com/
It was the bottle graphic that drew me in. I thought my son (definitely over 21) would get a hoot out of it so I bought it. I had no idea if it was any good, but the novelty alone was worth the price. Turns out we were lucky because it has now become a family fave.
Kraken rum is a good one - Have you tried their black cherry edition?
a great one to keep an eye out for is a Cornish rum called Dead Man's Fingers.
Dead Man's Fingers?!
It sounds like there is quite a story behind that name.