As I said I am all for it but see this as the problem, we should already be doing this as a community.

Absolutely, but we are not - at least not pushing together - and that's cool, we all have our communities.

It says that people are not already producing content good enough and no one is rewarding.

I think there is enough good content - but as above...

It is worth a try, and I hope more grace is given to those with lower Reps like 55 and under as that would be even more beneficial to onlookers that this place isn't a full circle jerk of the high reps.

I would love for the post that is seen by the reviewers who come and check what's been linked decide the best post/s is of a newer user. I don't want to decide on my own.

Cheers!