Valueplan in principal is a good idea and I see there is more content around some of the activities this time around but when you look into the detailed breakdown it still needs to be divided more evenly amongst more users. There should also be a cap on the amount one user can receive per year or at every funding round. These projects may be very good intentions and totally legit but right now they look like a way to drain money from the ecosystem to pursue their personnel goals or businesses. There are a few names that keep cropping up that Valueplan are giving HBD to on a weekly basis. Aside from the rally car that had its first outing last week , @marscrea is one that sticks out like a sore thumb. Since March 2022 there has been just under 110,000 HBD given to this account. The account is not active. It has a 25 rep and no posts so clearly an alt account of the 1 follower that the account follows. But there are no posts on that persons page around what the funds are going to. It might be legit but how are the Hive users to know? It may be a case where the user needs to write about what they are doing with the funds rather than have Valueplan post about it every six months. Should the funds not be transferred to SWC directly to make it more transparent because there is content around SWC on this page? I see some videos there with some gym equipment and a few hive banners and clothing but not enough to think this project is signing people up to Hive. Should there be a record of how many signups they got after each event because the events look very amateurish and look like they can be thrown together with a couple of hundred dollars. Some oversight possibly. Give any Hive user 108,000 HBD for a fitness project and most will post about it 3 to 4, 5 times a day and be happy about it. You could buy a GYM with that funding. 1960 HBD in total for a medical issue also. I guess they don't have health insurance then? What if this medical issue doesn't go away? Are Valueplan going to keep funding their medical expenses? (Hopefully) the 200 HBD will be the last of the expenses. I'm in the area of liability insurance and any events in most countries that take place in public or private buildings or beaches need to have liability insurance which will cover any accidents during the event. Talk about setting a precedent minefield. Laptop in flood last year and injured this year. This guy isn't blessed with luck. If there was more meat on the content bones maybe the 108,000 HBD is justifiable. There definitely should be a cap here of around 20-30k HBD. At the moment it is a free for all and I wouldn't blame these people. Also rather than get Hive users to advertise Hive , I wonder would it be more value to transfer 108,000 HBD to Binance, transfer it into FIAT( because this is what is being done anyway) hire a professional marketing company. Not a bad one now. 108HBD could get you one of the big 5 and get them to promote Hive. Get them to report their findings and copy and paste the marketing reports every 6 months. They will most likely focus on Tiktok which is all the rage now with advertisers. Spend 50k video marketing on Tiktok and see Hives userbase increase to a hell of alot more than we are trying to do currently. It just all makes more sense that to be dealing with the kind of stuff that I am seeing in the Valueplan's wallet.