Hello @ebargains, this contribution has been declined for the following reasons:
- It lacks technical details
- The idea lacks some vital information (Algorithm) on how it could be implemented
The idea on its own is not trivial as I believe every user should engaged in voting for witnesses. However, the reasons mentioned above makes it not valid and can not be rewarded.
Thank you for using utopian.
Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io.
Chat with us on Discord.
Hello @knowledges, the algorithm is actually suggested in the "Proposal" section: "propose that there is a financial reward/incentive for Steemians to participate in the witness selection process whereby the voters would receive anywhere from 0.1% to 5% (or more) of the witness' witness category post rewards as beneficiary payout rewards."
The actual % would have to be set by a Steem HF update, and it would have to be a fixed percentage for all witnesses.
On the technical side of things, there isn't much else to add since the beneficiary payout feature is already implemented, and all that needs to be done is for the witness category posts to have their beneficiary payouts set to let's say 1% and to be payed out to all of the Steem accounts that voted for them as a witness. It is all very straight forward and should be easily implemented.
And the additional witness information to be also available on the Witness voting page is a no-brainer:
"This proposal also involves adding the following extra columns to the https://steemit.com/~witnesses page:
Short witness biography and information with link to the witness' main blog page
Witness server and seed server specifications
Witness price feed info and missed blocks statistics
Witness Github contribution history
Witness' witness category post history and associated post rewards"
I think these changes will be implemented in the future, but what matters is when will that future become reality; in a few months or in a few years.
And @zoneboy already approved the contribution...