I think the ratings would get "real" if people needed to play the quests to earn their ranks so they could enter the tourneys. So I don't think you could make it to diamond with a level 6 deck or if you did they you would be a super talented player since that level would have mostly level 8 decks.

And they seem hellbent on letting the big decks play also in the small tourneys too (which I don't like, but its another convo). So if they made it so that you are capped at least at the level you make in the quest league, then that would limit the people from playing as they are supposedly worried about.

I think if they did that though it would make more people want to play the quests and the fight to get ranked to a good level would be legit. So I doubt it would be all robots like we have experienced in the past.

I hope it helps and I don't think you are in danger of them taking any of my proposals. I think I've crossed swords with Aggy too much to ever put that genie back in the bottle.