Sort:  

To be fair, what doesn't crack you up? You're one of those people who make me go "Yay, I'm funny!" And then you laugh at a really mediocre joke I make. And it's like "Well, okay."

And then it happens the 10th time that you laugh at a joke that lacks any effort at all, and it becomes evident that I'm actually not funny, you just laugh at everything.

And to add a disclaimer: I was joking to @stellabelle (Let's test out this new feature). I just don't use smileys outside of chat environments.