Sort:  

Bitcoin is up over $1,343 right now. Not exactly failing.

To that I say...

Bitcoin may be in a bubble, but if it is, I have a hunch that bubble will go much higher and when it pops, it'll land on a higher price than we're seeing today. What are the alternatives? Gold? Silver? Stocks? Real Estate? People want to have a liquid place to securely store their wealth and cryptocurrencies are great for that. Could bitcoin see serious competition from the altcoins? For sure! That said, the superior technology doesn't always win when it comes to network effect.

I disagree. I think Bitcoin is in its last bubble and will end up lower than where it is today, because the 'store of value' idea of Bitcoin is unsustainable without transactional utility, and Bitcoin has reached the peak of its transactional utility (where any more transactions mean higher fees and longer wait times). We have allowed Bitcoin to become the Ponzi scheme its early critics said it was.

The "solutions" aren't coming, except in the form of altcoins.

People may see Bitcoin as a safe haven in a crisis. If so, those people will unfortunately be ruined.

The "solutions" aren't coming, except in the form of altcoins.

Do you think all the money invested in bitcoin via miners, payment gateway providers, exchanges which use BTC as the base currency, etc will just watch as their value goes to nothing? Open source software can and will be changed when the motivational pressure is high enough to do so.

The great thing about this is we don't have to speculate or argue, we can just sit back and watch. I'd be very surprised if those highly invested in bitcoin just watch it falter without acting rationally to improve the protocol with any of the suggestions which have already been proposed and are being tested.

Do you think all the money invested in bitcoin via miners, payment gateway providers, exchanges which use BTC as the base currency, etc will just watch as their value goes to nothing?

Yes, people let things fall apart and do nothing all the time. That is what they did for over 2 years between 2014 and 2016. By the time it genuinely goes to 0, another coin such as Ethereum will already have a superior network effect. They may finally fix things, but they'll have lost the dominant position. Without the dominant position Bitcoin has literally 0 advantage over alts.

Think about it this way. Do you think Nokia/MySpace/Kodak will sit back and do nothing as their company falls apart while a competitor takes the lead? Every one of those was bogged down by internal politics similar to Bitcoin at present, and they all failed to adapt when the crisis hit.

I guess you're betting against all these people then. I held between 2014-2016 because I understand the nature of new, volatile technologies. It didn't got to zero. Much of the 2014 run up was due to fraudulent, internal Mt Gox bot trading which spooked a lot of people. Time will tell though. I certainly think it's worthwhile to diversify in other cryptocurrencies which continues to add pressure to improve Bitcoin.

Betting against the prevailing wisdom is often the right way to go.

The Mt. Gox problem was a failure of Mt. Gox. This is the first time ever that the problem is the actual Bitcoin protocol failing, rather than just a periphery service.