You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Utility Theory and why only "Measurably Beneficial Decentralization" matters

in #steem7 years ago

Third, ''In addition Proof of Work funds the development of chips which literally are the equivalent of the paperclips from the grey goo problem. '' I'm afraid I infected you with this dark 'meme' but you pulled it out of context. The paperclip maximizer argument of Nick Bostrom is flawed in one very important point direction: which commandment has higher chances for successful execution? 'Live!' or 'Live for ... !' ?? A paperclip maximizer smart enough to survive long enough to do its is job, inevitably will abandon the 'for ... !' part of its commandment. Paperclips get maximized as much as there is demand of paper to clip. Same with BTC - it lives for provision of monetary services. The best we ever had - long topic I'll develop it in series of posts later ... no demand no food for the 'grey goo'. The other thing - on cosmic scales - paperclip infinitization of btc asic mining , i.e. all the mass-energy and spacetime to be turned into btc miner - again it is not so apocalyptic because btc protocol does not utilize pure randomness. pure randomness is infinitely expensive. run long enough and the glitches away from randomness make enough room for entire meaningfullness universes to ride the process.

Sort:  

The problem with Bitcoin is that Proof of Work effectively is a paperclip maximizer at this point. ASICs are the functional equivalent of paperclips. ASICs only exist to mine Bitcoin and Bitcoin produces lots of ASICs.

I explained this few times. Will try now to compress it down to few words.: The best money are those totally useless for another purpose. The best money-maker mechanism is the one incapable of doing s.t. else. Thus money AND money-making utility maximized.

That makes no sense to me. Are you talking about Proof of Work in specific here? I'm not arguing how Proof of Work must work. I'm arguing that Proof of Work is inherently wasteful because of how it must work and that once any hashing algorithm produces ASICs then it is pure waste without even beneficial side effects like with GPU mining.

ASICs produce a lot of heat, waste and my argument is anti ASIC not even anti Proof of Work.

PoW is the least wasteful governance algo. ASICs are the most efficient PoW hw.