Screwing the World’s Poor for $16 Billion? Steem and SD Can Cut the Cost of Money Transfers and Take Down the Predatory Remittance Industry

in #steem8 years ago (edited)

p

We can help the world's poor and gain up to $600 billion in annual volume

The world has a huge “unbanked” population. In developing countries where there is little opportunity to succeed, many individuals and families depend on remittances (international money transfers) from their relatives abroad. Overall, these money transfers account for $600 billion in annual volume.

Unfortunately, three large companies have monopolized this money flow to the world’s “unbanked” population. They are conspiring to charge extremely high fees, as much as 5%-12% on the money they transfer. This burden falls heaviest on the “unbanked” who often have no other option to get the money they need.

Western Union, Moneygram, Ria, and their various brand names are pocketing the lion’s share of the $16 billion that this industry rakes in every year. Shame on them for taking so much money from some of the world’s poorest and neediest people.

Fortunately, the world doesn’t need their overpriced infrastructure to send money anymore. Something better has arrived.

How do Remittances Work?

Remittances are cross-border money transfers. Immigrants get jobs in relatively rich countries, earning wages that can seem like a fortune in their home countries. Often, they send money home to their families in developing countries. There is a huge outflow from the wealthier countries like the United States ($56 billion transferred out), Russia ($32 billion transferred out), Saudi Arabia ($36 billion transferred out), and the United Kingdom ($11.6 billion transferred out).

c
d

Meanwhile, on the other side, money flows in. In a recent year, people in India received over $70 billion in remittances, people in China $62 billion, people in Mexico almost $25 billion, and people in the Philippines $27 billion. In some smaller countries, the inflow of remittances from abroad makes up a huge share of the gross domestic product (GDP). In Haiti, for example, remittances account for more than 22% of the country’s economy.

Others with a large proportion include El Salvador, Honduras, Jamaica, and Estonia (remittances from abroad account for around 16-17% of the GDP in each country); Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan (30% and 36% respectively); Moldova, Tonga, and Nepal (all 26%-29%). Way down the list, but still relying on remittances as an important part of their significant economies include Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Egypt, Morocco, Pakistan, and Vietnam (all in the 6-9% range).

Startups to the rescue? Not so fast.

A new generation of startups is attempting to undercut Western Union, Moneygram, and Ria. Though none of them has gained real traction yet, they are posing enough of a challenge that the industry leaders have been lowering their prices for the last year or two. This is excellent news for the world’s poor, but something much better is on the horizon.

The problem with these startups is that each of them relies on a system that is inferior to Steem. WorldRemit, for example, aims to let people transfer money digitally using mobile phones. TransferWise, which is probably the furthest along of any of these startups, has been carving out a market share as the first remittance company that enables true peer-to-peer transactions. While both of these would be an improvement over Western Union-style transfers, any system that does not use cryptocurrency is already overpriced and outdated. The blockchain will always be cheaper.

Ripple Labs created the first real cryptocurrency network. Its concept of using third party gateways for exchange and transfers has been a pioneering vision and it’s provided a blueprint for others to follow. But in the end, the currency has failed to catch on because of its cost and the perception that it is over-centralized. A network with so little community buy in would simply become a cryptocurrency version of the money transfer system that banks use now. The same goes for any other back-end blockchain that the banks may create for themselves.

Other startups such as ZipZap and Remitly have worked to integrate Bitcoin, either explicitly or as a back-end method of transferring value. But Bitcoin’s problems have only accelerated in recent months, making it a less than ideal choice. The mining is expensive and a huge waste of energy. There are governance issues. The Bitcoin network can barely handle its own transaction load, let alone a huge increase in use. Transactions are slow and they do cost money, even if it isn’t much. Bitcoin blazed a trail as the first generation cryptocurrency, but there are far better alternatives today.

We have a solution in the making! “No fee” transactions and more.

Steem and Steem Dollars provide a way to transfer value without paying transaction fees. Steem applies a 21st Century blockchain solution to a problem that has plagued the world for decades….no, for centuries. Millennia? I’m not religious, but moneychangers were mentioned in the Bible (try Matthew 21:12, where Jesus threw them out of the temple). So that goes back at least 2000 years.

Throughout our history, when people have needed to change and move money, others have been there to profit from that exchange. There is nothing wrong with capitalizing on a good business opportunity. But when you are making billions of dollars by squeezing some of the poorest people and countries on the planet, then it’s time for you to go.

tc

A better model: Click, click, money received!

Steem and Steem Dollars are free to use, instant to send, tightly secure, and backed by their own economy: NO OTHER alternative can offer these features. Together, these advantages make Steem and Steem Dollars the best possible basis upon which to build a money transfer framework.

Hopefully, some of the promising remittance startups will consider building around Steem or Steem Dollars. If they don’t, then someone else will. There is big money potential for the one that is ‘first to market’ with an app or network built around Steem. Perhaps it will be someone from the Steemit community who rises up to take on this challenge.

However, there is far more demand than any one company can meet, especially given the unique business climates in each country. There is room for many remittance companies in this space, all operating in different regions or with different niches. If they partner with one another and cooperate on technology, then we could help the world’s poor much more quickly.

The catch is that we are just getting started. The Steem economy is young. There are very few merchants and gateways that can accept Steem or Steem Dollars yet. Until we have more user-friendly off-ramps, people who are undereducated and not technology savvy will have a hard time going through the steps needed to “cash out” into fiat currency.

Of course, there is no need to wait. At least SOME of that $600 billion per year is being transferred to people who know how to use computers. They may not be the poorest of the poor, who need to cash out every cent to buy food, shelter, or medical supplies. But they may well need money for other important reasons: buying an airplane ticket, paying for a wedding, or completing college. We can start with them.

Steem and Steem Dollars are tools to help the world

We have Steemit community members in dozens of countries. So let’s encourage everyone we know to begin using Steem or Steem Dollars to transfer monetary value. They can use STEEM if they want something liquid and easily convertible, or Steem Dollars if they prefer the price stable feature.

Your friends and family members do not need to be bloggers or voters to have a Steemit account. The wallet on Steemit is well built. You can use it to send and receive currency with a few clicks of a button.

With Steemit getting all the attention so far, it’s easy to forget that we are supported by these truly revolutionary currency tokens. Steemit’s growth can help a lot of people, but Steem’s growth will help even more. While we enjoy the Steemit platform, let’s start using its currencies to make the world better.

f

Sources:

Global Remittances by amount and as percentage of GDP: http://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/global-remittances-guide

Startups in Remittance Field: https://www.cbinsights.com/blog/disrupting-western-union-moneygram/

More on Startups: https://www.saveonsend.com/blog/money-transfer-startups/

TransferWise CEO’s Reddit AMA:

Battle for Int’l Money Transfers: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/transferwise-on-bitcoin-and-the-battle-for-international-money-transfers-1453996516

#steem
#money

Sort:  
There are 2 pages
Pages

Brilliant! Back with a bang! Glad to finally read a post from you...And you wowed me as usual..... :)

I completely agree with you.... The key to the adoption of steemit - steem and SD is the no fees advantage....

I, personally, have used MoneyGram and Western Union to receive funds from relatives and those guys are CROOKS... Their exchange rates are far lower than the market rate. They shortchange you and keep you waiting for hours with nauseating excuses.....

Last month, I exchanged a few SD to my local currency......And that was the first time ever that I would get the full worth of my money.....

Ive got plans on how we can maximize this advantage esp for Africa...

Splendid! Welcome back, Tom.... You rock... :)

Oh, so exciting Info! I am so happy that you're seeing how to change things for Africa, and you are the best one for the job. You've taught me so much.

@infovore , Is it true as you say it is?

Don't forget bitUSD from Bitshares could also be great for remittance :D

You have to have a bank account to get the money out so the unbanked(smart) ones can't really benefit from this ponzi scheme.

https://steemit.com/steemit/@apocaloptimisto/dantheman-ned-please-remove-my-content-from-this-site

Dont need a bank account to get a Bitcoin-based debit/credit card...

The fees usually emerge when it's time to convert into fiat. Especially in countries like Russia, where the ruling mafia to this day couldn't firmly decide if it have to ban all cryptocurrencies permanently or just to parasitize on its users by taxes and fines.
Despite that, there are always a ways, but also there are always a costs.

Good point. Yes, when I researched this, I found that the fee can go a lot higher with the monetary conversion in most places, which is not a big surprise. For this article, I tried to ignore that part for simplicity's sake, but it is a big issue in its own right. Hopefully, if the transfer fee is low enough (free?), then the currency exchange will not add too much more to the cost. But there will always be some costs, unless and until people can pay for what they need directly with Steem or Steem Dollars.

@donkeypong @cuckoo If STEEMIT really takes off (and hence STEEM too) then businesses may start accepting STEEM or SBD for payment anyway - in this case the fees could be slashed since the business itself would not have to pay any third party for the transaction.

That is the big hope with most cryptos actually just with Steemit/STEEM it could happen before it does for other cryptos due to the low barrier for entry.

Doubt it.

There are many benefits of government backed fiats.

Government intervention to control exchange rate. Discretionary economic intervention for flexibility in protecting monetary value and favorable economic conditions.

Those are all advantages for governments and not necessarily good for the end user.

I would prefer to let the market decide those things and not have the government constantly fiddling with things or printing more money whenever they feel like it.

That is why fiat money will eventually be replaced by cryptocurrencies.

It's a question of when rather than if.

Yeah right, I so agree with you @cuckoo

Yeap, goverments of the some country soo love to control all. Cryptocurrencies give some freedom to ppl and these goverments afraid it.

Is this correct? May be billion?

people in China $62 million, people in Mexico almost $25 million

@vi1son , This real and billions.

Yes, you are correct. Thank you for catching my mistake. I've fixed it now.

What would the practical advantages be of Steem/SBD being used over Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency?

Removing our personal attachment to Steemit and assessing the matter objectively - what are the specific benefits Steem/SBD has for such an application that other cryptocurrencies do not, at this point?

Great post , yes one day steem will replace bitcoin ,cheers steemers :)

Loading...

Wow well researched, expressed and documented. I have had to use Western Union in the past and it's slow to do, slow to go and EXPENSIVE! You are helping people here realise that Steem is much more than just social media. IT IS A CURRENCY and it is gaining mass adoption world wide. Has @kencode implemented it into his smartphone app? Did you see his latest post! Exciting times indeed! Thanks again!

i am sorry but, steem has only a trading volume of 250.000 USD per day. even Dash with 1.000.000 has 4x that amount. there is 0 adoption yet.

if we want adoption, i suggest everybody starts buying steem right now

1000 new users per day is not bad adoption in my book and we haven't got to critical mass. Once we get to 10,000 new users per day, you'll see real adoption for sure.

Much respect to you sir. I really think we underestimate the true power of Steem and Steem Dollars. We have a technology which can be world changing. One day I will be able to tell my kids that I was part in creating a better world :)

Steemit is gonna change the way do a LOT of things. It will be a greater revolution that the internet itself. I imagine a world where Steemit proves to be a healing potion for the ailing population. :)

I talk about a future with Steemit in it, in this post:
https://steemit.com/steemit/@sauravrungta/in-a-dark-world-steemit-proves-to-be-a-ray-of-sunshine-originalcontent-a-steemit-original

Hot damn @donkeypong, you are entirely right.

Oh, the glorious possibilities of this scaled blockchain.........

If we are talking about helping the poor, though, we need to make it possible for them to actually get CASH, and it should be something that can be used without a smartphone / connectivity. We're not yet at the point where we can replace cash with digital, though we may be close. So, I am officially asking for ideas that work along these lines:

The steemit community should jointly design and entirely give away a

  • SBD<->Cash
  • BTC<->Cash
  • etc <-> etc

...business model.

This would enable countless people to make a living using the blockchain and even more people to get money when they need it. Yes, we want to eventually get rid of the moneychangers, but by starting in this less ambitious place, we can help more people, more directly, with their problems today.

I'm thinking of something that is literally no more complicated that a roadside stand that can be operated by one person with a smartphone / PC. This would hearld an incredible change in the dynamics of money globally.

I'm actually starting steem to cash this week... its probably not going to be huge, but im hoping others will follow suit. One of the key barriers to steem value taking off is decoupling from BTC

On the web? In meatspace? GPS coordinates? URL?

:)

the url is steembroker.com but i didnt want to mention it before it was actually up, which its not yet.

The remittance companies like WR and transferwise are already circling the drain. Yeah, they can do it cheaper than WU and MG, but they also get hammered by fraud because they cut corners.

That said, to play devils advocate, as long buying and selling steem is primarily bitcoin mediated, bitcoin is going have a huge advantage in cross border money transfer.

As someone who works primarily in this area (moving international money) things like instantaneous transactions (versus waiting 30 mins) or no transaction fee (vs a fee of a few cents on thousands of dollars) just arent significant enough to overcome the first actor advantage.

All that said, they have to actually get transfers that reliably work before any of this "disruption" becomes an issue.

any system that does not use cryptocurrency is already overpriced and outdated. blockchain will always be cheaper https://t.co/bYw2qoxak4

— Jupiter (@Jupiter00000) August 1, 2016

Jupiter00000 Jupiter tweeted @ 01 Aug 2016 - 21:48 UTC

any system that does not use cryptocurrency is already overpriced and outdated. blockchain will always be cheaper steemit.com/steem/@donkeyp...

Disclaimer: I am just a bot trying to be helpful.

It'll take some time to stabilize the steem and SD markets, but when that is done, why not...

Nice article.
My opinion is that STEEM will not be the next remittance solution for the under banked as it's not the best store of value and probably light years after Bitcoin in payment adoption. Also the fees taken to transfer STEEM>BITCOIN>$ will probably be like the average WU fees.
I do think it can be the platform to help the under banked earn money from creativity and participation. We have already seen some stories of 3rd world country residence earning money from Steemit.

It's nice to have you back creating awesome content. Great insights Donkey!

Providing sources and explaining everything in details. You are the reason why this platform is as successful as it is.

I'm a 27 yr old male, very close to becoming homeless. I don't know what to say anymore. I could write you up one of those 'steemit articles about steemit' where I'll write things like "you just need to be original and bring good content to the table if you want votes." Those posts - I've seen so many of them, and they do pretty well. But they're not original. Not even fucking close. Go check out some of the actual original artists & musicians popping up on this site - 1 dollar, maybe a cent for their song or painting - probably something that took weeks to write in comparison to some cliche article about Steemit. Such a fucking pity that people can't just branch out and help one another even when it's a vote that doesn't cost the person a cent. Fucked up. This isn't a rat race. It's a minnow race.

@shredlord
The economy is brutal, so god damned brutal man. I am voluntarily homeless. I live out of $10-20 per night hotels and work in a coworking space and love it. I do this for the freedom that it gives me. Here's my point though man: The second that you stop trying to solve this for you, and start trying to SOLVE THIS is also the second that your ideas will begin to get traction.

Also, even though it's hard (and if you look through my social media posts, you'll see I've failed many a time) -- NO WHINING! Yessir, you're whining.

There are more great ways to make money than I can think of in a year. Choose one, and go with it. If it doesn't work, choose another.

2 key takeaways:

  • Whining is a disincentive people to help you
  • YOU CAN DO THIS. WHATEVER IT IS-- JUST.... DO IT. It'll be harder than you think now, and it'll be worth it.

Wow. This statement is that of a true champion. 🎖✊

Any online currencies can replace money transfer will be easier over 10 billion marketcap.

What fundamentals do you base that $10billion figure on?

Curious as to the reasons you see that value affecting the system dynamics...

Its difficult to think if some "predatory" enterprise like xoom only take 1% of fee, and if you like to change usd to bitcoin the "saving" enterprise take 1,5% and from bitcoin to usd 1,5% , what is predatory?

good post @donkeypong
nice to see you writing something since one week ago! 8]

Money trafer has around for a long time. Cryto currenies have tried many times to replace it but no luck with it. I think because of people lack of awareness.

The tech, models, and systems is one side of the issue - the education required for successful adoption is definitely another, and the more difficult of the two...

Bitcoin has already been around and could potentially be a viable alternative to many - but yet, lack of awareness and knowledge...

The art world has come comrades.

Yeah, i have found out that many people claims that bitcoin, and other " new " btc related inventions can help the world, and finish world poverty.
Obviously, all is that not true, steemit cannot also. It is a great tool with many ways to use, but you cannot expect that some website is going to change the whole world.

Help out poor people by yourself, and hope that it will finish their problems!
If you think that you have done not enough, then help more! Steemit is not a way for this. Doing it by yourself- it is an ultimate way to spread the happinness :)

True. Will go and open an account for my grandma! I'm sure she could write amazing posts.

Outstanding article here. The technology is here now to make steem feasible for remittances. The question now is how do we get people to adopt it?

You can send Bitcoin via text message so as long as you've got 3G, then game on. Don't see why this can't be done with other assets like Steem as you say.

So many developing countries use non fiat backed assets for currency such as phone cards, which are traded on the black market , hold their value and work perfectly well. Would be nice to hear your thoughts on these less mainstream items?...

Also, having Steem pegged to the USD might turn out to be an Achilles heel in the wrong market conditions.

It can be changed as and when needed.

WOW, make $ 2000 in 16 min> that's well paid !!!

Top post, at 600b to get even 5% back to the poor would be absolutely brilliant

We must stop the banks from robbing us.

👍great post, nice article @donkeypong

This is totally awesome, i have been trying to figure out how to help countries in Africa with the current FX restrictions they have. and reading this opened my eyes.Thank you.

You know that when you take money from somewhere actually someone has less money right ? By taking away banking fees you are also taking away banking jobs. Less banking fees = more jobless people.

If Steem were an alternative...

How many of those people out of jobs could earn the same amount on Steemit?

And considering the monthly wages in Africa are probably a fraction of what they are in North America - people wouldn't need to be rocking out hard to earn the same as a basic wage working at a bank...

You know that when you don't take money from somewhere the person actually spends it to satisfy an even higher level desire, right? The difference in the level of desire satisfied is called additional prosperity.

Your comment is simply a variation on the broken window fallacy: If the window was not broken, the glazier would not make money. This only appears a valid argument until you consider the owner of the window also has other needs and wants. You can analyze the seen (glazier gets paid) but completely ignore the unseen (tailor does not).

It's easy to see how fallacious this is: See if your opinion changes on the situation if you find out the glazier is paying a commission to some rascals for each window broken.

This is a wonderful concept @donkeypong . It would be great to see this come to life in the near future. Can't wait to see it happen.

Great post! Thanks!

This anti-poverty capability is what got me interested in cryptocurrency a couple years ago. This TED video was the catalyst for a new way of thinking about cryptocurrency, when I suddenly realized what is possible with remittances for the unbanked: http://www.ted.com/talks/dilip_ratha_the_hidden_force_in_global_economics_sending_money_home

Cryptocurrency is only the tip of the ice berg, though. Keeping property and financial records on the blockchain takes it to a whole new level.

Amazing idea and great post! Welcome back by the way!

This a win-win-win the poor in money restricted countries get a shot, steemit grows, and we become better by helping them :)

I love the story about the temple too. Chasing the money changers.

@donkeypong, wow, what an excellent article. I've often thought about all of this, and now it seems possible. I've use 2 of the 3 you mentioned, and yes, indeed I was ripped off.

I used to pay my workers in the Philippines via PayPal, and I often covered the cost of the fees, but even still it added up. So #SteemDollars all the way I say. :)

That's one of the reason why my twin and I applied to M.I.T program into blockchain and cryptocurrency to get into blockchain and cryptocurrency because of this vast potential that changes world wide to the unbankable. Even happens here in U.S too. not many banks branches here at city with low poverty except payday advances. not really helpful. Those two tech can help if more people are using and knowing about this as this hits mainstream.

p.s donkey kong was taken wasn't it? :)

Slightly off-topic, but how did you find the MIT program?

I'm considering taking their Fintech one next year - curious if you feel it's of great value...

We found about the MIT program from people at Google Angeles Labs. America got in. I didn't but I got some very exciting news on what I recently got accepted to which just found out a couple days ago and getting papers finalized (course I added sis, too as she is on my team and understands what we are working on)...so you gonna have to find out in a few days ;) cheer for your fellow steemians !!!

personally i am not putting my money in steem at this time. All cryptocurrencies are new and vulnerable and seem prone to hacks and attacks. Steem is no different and i do not see it as a replacement for @bitcoin. If so...then @steemit is my everyday play money and not my primary money for savings, bills, etc. If you promote yourself as a social media platfrom stick with social media not as a cryptocurrency exhange platform between your friends. The more you meddle and attempt to alter/add purpose and components the more likely you are to encounter attacks. @steemit stay true to what you are.

Great post, keep up the good research. This is quite important. I've been thinking about this for the last year or so. Stability of currency is also important, as you allude to. If Steem ends up focusing and niching on social media more than cross border currency, maybe ideas such as koin technology presented at k0in.com will be important. This site is still in idea stage, but I hope to introduce it soon on Steem.

Great article! Tons of Information for the "non-crypto" person to digest. Steemit accomplishes more than just writing great articles. It solves a real world problem with sending money across borders for free. Not even Bitcoin can achieve that! Hold on tight folks...The world is coming!!!

This is what I like to see. Leveraging technology to defeat cruelty, supplanting it with gentleness.

That's fucking awesome.

good article, you should never be punished for being poor

There are 2 pages
Pages