You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: SPS Governance Proposal - Adjust Brawl Rewards

The main objective of the proposal is to encourage all guilds to rise to tier 4 and tier 5 of the arena by offering an additional percentage of crowns and merits (14%) to those who remain between quarrels 4 to 10. Therefore, If you are between positions 1 to 3, you are invited to go up to the next tier where you will surely obtain places from 4 to 10 and possibly earn merits, crowns and SPS similar to the previous tier or even better. All this is going well and since I have been in tier 2, tier 3 and tier 4 with different accounts this year, I can attest that the rewards in a higher tier are equal or better even if I am among the last places.

However, this bonus would be given by deducting it precisely from positions 1 to 3, since they are a minority and the proposal would surely end up being approved. Out of respect for these clans that for years have strived to bring together the best Splinterland players in the same guild and maintain consistency during that time, it seems to me that they should be consulted first if they agree to take that step as a incentive for other guilds to level up.

On the other hand, leveling up is not easy, you need money to complete the buildings, find players for the new gold foil fights and make the members understand that the first Brawl could be humiliating but that they must be brave and resilient. An additional 14% bonus on merits and crowns may not be what a clan is looking for when they want to level up.

What I want to say with all this is that perhaps the proposed proposal is not fair since there is a subject who will be harmed and a beneficiary who may not notice that additional 14% that is being offered, because the main objective of Each guild will continue to be in the first places.

Sort:  

Before we run this proposal it was discussed nearly a month, first in discord and than in this post:

https://hive.blog/splinterlands/@schachoberhessen/splinterlands-dao-proposal-remove-the-reward-reducting-for-brawl-tiers-with-less-than-10-guilds-participating-and-remove-the

Than it run one week as preprosal, visible for everybody who want see it at Peakmonsters and Splex and we even don in this phase (preprosal) a change by removing the top3-bonus only for crownes and merits and not for SPS.

So I think it was all open and everybody could discuss.
IMO it is not the best way to just come after all is decided and the real proposal run already when it was so long before time to address all issues and I think if a guild is really interested than somebody of this guild can also look once a week if their is a guild-related topic and must not wait for an extra invitation.