Can Cinnamon Help Reduce The Obesity Epidemic? Cinnamon Has Been Observed To Convert White Fat To Brown Fat

in #science7 years ago (edited)

Obesity, it's becoming quite an issue in the developed world. Sure, there are a number of causes for that and many of them we bring upon our selves. Acknowledging that doesn't make access to good healthy food options a viable reality for many people, nor does it change the plethora of diseases that come about because of obesity such as: type 2 diabetes, heart disease, cancer, high blood pressure, and that's just to name a few! [1]

Today we will discuss a research article published May 26, 2016 in the journal Nature: Scientific Reports titled "Cinnamon induces browning in subcutaneous adipocytes". Which is an article discussing of all things... the ability that cinnamon has in converting white fat to brown fat.


White Fat... Brown Fat...? I Thought Fat Was Fat and That Was That

In the body, fat is stored in specialized cells called adipocyte cells. Which I am sure many of you are aware of (so wait @justtryme90, hold the presses, your telling me fat is stored in fat cells... duhhhh). Yes...

However what you may be unaware of is that there are two classes of adipocytes in the body, one called white and the other called brown. White adipocytes are basically a little bit of cytoplasm and a big blob of fat molecules (lipids!). Brown adipocytes are a bit more structured, and contain a whole bunch of mitochondria (which you know are THE POWERHOUSE OF THE CELL!!!).

These mitochondria are the reason that the brown adipocytes having a brown color. Brown adipocytes are the cellular component of what we call Brown Fat, which is something that babies have a lot of to keep them warm (all those mitochondria generate lots of ATP and that can be used in conjunction with a protein named uncoupling protein 1 to generate heat through a process called "non-shivering" thermogenesis). [3]

This generation of heat seems like a great way to use up energy and burn up those stored lipids in the fat cells right? Unfortunately for us non babies, the amount of brown fat in the body is thought to progressively decline as we age with older people having less and less of it.


My easy weight loss plan!!!

So Wait, These Authors Were Looking At Cinnamon...?

Yeah, Cinnamon. They were looking at cinnamon extract in relation to a process called browning, which is a way that the body can increase the numbers of a particular kind of brown fat cell (as if there would be only one kind... tch... this is science, and biology no less. We crave as many classifications for things as possible! ) called a brite cell (it's actually a white fat cell that expresses lots of the uncoupling protein 1 found in the brown fat cell mitochondria... and the jury is still out on whether it is REALLY a brown fat cell, but lets leave the arguing about that distinction to the scientists who don't have anything better to do but argue about the classifications of fat cells and just call it a brown fat cell).

Interestingly Cinnamon has been found to have a variety of beneficial effects on the body including anti-inflammatory functions, and increased metabolism.[4], [5] However no studies had looked at the effects of cinnamon extract on this adipocyte browning process. So the authors of this article set out to change that.

Lets Take A Look At Some Of Their Interesting Results

Cinnamon Extract Reduces The Lipid Content Of Adipose Cells


Source: Figure 2

One of the first things they did was to look at the amount of lipid (fat) molecules present in some white adipose cells before, and after treatment with cinnamon extract. To do this they used a red dye called "Oil Red O" which stains lipids. (A) shows you the white adipose cells, filled with nice big blobs of fat.. mmmmmm... I mean yuck. (B) shows you the cells after a 24-hour treatment with the cinnamon extract (80 ug/mL). You can see that those bit blobs of fat are now broken up into smaller blobs, and there appears to be less. The authors quantified the relative amounts in each, and that is plotted in (C). There is a statistically significant reduction in the quantity of lipids in the cells (as judged by the amount of Oil Red O) after treatment with the cinnamon extract.

Cinnamon Extract Increases Expression of uncoupling protein 1 in white adipose tissue


Source: Figure 3

Here is a plot of the amount of mRNA (the instructions which tell the cell to make a particular protein) encoding for the protein uncoupling protein 1 (Ucp1). We can see that in the cells the relative amount of this protein is drastially increased after treatment with the cinnamon extract (CE in the legend of the graph above). If you recall what we talked about earlier was that this protein is responsible for the energy burning, heat generating (thermogenesis) performed in brown fat mitochondria!

So far we see that the amount of lipids in the cells decreases, and the amount of uncoupling protein 1 increases upon treatment of some cells with a cinnamon extract.

The Increased Uncoupling Protein 1 Comes With An Increase In Number of Mitochondria


Source: Figure 3

So here the authors were using a stain (MitoTracker Green) that specifically targets and stains mitochondria. Ironically despite its name of MitoTracker Green, they colored their figure red... anyway. So here on the looking at untreated (top) and cinnamon extract treated (bottom) cells. The panes on the left are with the mitochondrial stain, and on the right are just a regular light microscope image so you can see where the whole cells are at. What is clear from this picture is that the amount of mitochondria present are increased in the CE treated cells (they are much brighter with the mitochondrial stain then the control untreated cells).

Taking Things A Step Further... To The Mouse Model (as usual!!!)

So things were looking pretty interesting in a cell based model, really looks like the cinnamon extract is leading to a conversion from a white adipose cell, to a brown adipose cell (decreased lipid content, increased mitochondria, and increased uncoupling protein 1 are all hallmark characteristics of brown adipose tissue). The authors confirmed that these results were reproducible when similar experiments were performed on adipose cells extracted directly from obese mice (it's in the paper but for the sake of the length of this already long post I won't show it)

Now the authors wanted to see whether or not giving obese mice cinnamon extract orally, reduced body weight and increased the expression of the uncoupling protein 1.


Source: Figure 8

So they fed the mice a high fat diet to cause weight gain in the mice, some of the mice also ate a whole bunch of cinnamon extract (500 mg/kg body weight, jeez that's a lot for me that would be about 1/10 of 1 lb of cinnamon extract LOL) daily for 15 straight days. What you see above is that the body weight of the mice who were not consuming the cinnamon extract steadily went up, while the body weight of the mice receiving the cinnamon did not. Interesting.

The authors looked into why this was and found that the only indicator that could explain the lack of weight gain in the cinnamon mice, was an increase in the expression levels of uncoupling protein 1 in their fat tissue.

Conclusions

The authors showed here that cinnamon extract was able to significantly increase the expression levels of uncoupling protein 1 in both a cell and mouse model. Uncoupling protein 1 is involved in the thermogenesis process and extra heat generation burns calories and can lead to weight loss.

The authors data shows that supplementation with cinnamon extract helped to keep mice being fed a high fat diet from gaining as much weight as their counterparts not receiving the cinnamon. In all their data suggests that cinnamon may be a way to help combat the obesity epidemic, as it appears to be able to increase the generation of brown fat cells (which as we discussed above goes away as we age).

Sources

  1. http://glahder.dk/engelsk/obesity/obesity-Roland-Sturm.pdf
  2. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-02263-5
  3. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16513826
  4. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18424588
  5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2602825/
  6. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2446425/

All Non Cited Images Are From Pixabay.com And Are Available Under Creative Commons Licenses

Any Gifs Are From Giphy.com and Are Also Available for Use Under Creative Commons Licences

Images from figures in Nature: Scientific Reports articles are available for reuse under a Creative Commons license (all figures will be appropriately attributed and linked back to the article of reference).


If you like this work, please consider giving me a follow: @justtryme90. I am here to help spread scientific knowledge and break down primary publications in such a way so as to cut through the jargon and provide you the main conclusions in short (well compared to the original articles at least!) and easy to read posts.

Sort:  

Great article! Actually I wanted to write a comment, but ... sorry, I am just on my way to the kitchen now ... and what do you think I am seeking there? It begins with c ... :-)

You are seeking, a carrot. ;)

Thanks for your error corrections.

Another most excellent post!

Thanks for the education and what I had also been noticing in myself as well! Maybe there will be room for the #education next time?!? ;)

Namaste :)

Thank you for the kind words! I am glad you found the post interesting, that is the most important part for me. If people are able to read what I am writing about and take something away from it (hopefully a bit of better understanding of some aspect of the biological topics within) then the world will be a better place.

Mice are not humans, and the brown fat down regulates in summer, because no one wants to be running a fever because they have to much BAT. it is a good thing to research, it just will not be the silver bullet there is a reason that humans do not naturally have the higher % of BAT compared with other species... look into it

Very true that the mouse model cannot be used to explain digestive behaviour in humans entirely. There will always be some tiny but significant differences. However, there is quite a chance that cinnamon actually does* work as described in humans as well. If it does, I personally will be on the safe side as I just love cinnamon and tend to eat lots of it. If not, I still have the pleasure to enjoy its taste every day. ;-)

@justtryme90, Are you aware of any human trials in this context?

No I am not. Typically the use of models like rat, mouse, dog etc. Preceeds any sort of human trial. I don't suspect that this result will inspire a human trial either. It's positive and quite interesting, but actual human trials cost millions... I don't think people would valuate these findings as worth the money risk.

At least not in the US. However this was a Chinese research group. So perhaps things would be viewed differently there? I don't know.

Very true but if this "cinnamon link" turns out to be significant, I'm pretty sure that some larger company might be interested in conducting some studies.But we'll see... I hope we'll at least see some further basic research in this area.

I suspect they won't if only because there wouldn't be a way to monetize cinnamon. Perhaps I am being too cynical.

I only described the research to the best of my ability. I don't suspect it will be the silver bullet :)

I did think this paper was interesting however.

Thank you for reading and commenting.

Very interesting points to consider regarding human biology. Thanks @justtryme90
I also have posted blogs about my research in Parasitology.
You can find one of the posts here https://steemit.com/health/@kajalpats/why-you-should-care-about-eating-meat
Thanks!

Thank you for reading and your kind words :)

Much informative and beautifully written. Obesity is a increasing cause. It will be nice if it can be controlled by changing some eating habits. There must be some good recipes of cinnamon

Indeed, if a simple solution can be found it would be quite beneficial to a whole lot of people! It's important to remember that these studies are just one data point in a sea of work necessary to really show that something is beneficial. However at least cinnamon isn't going to hurt you (unless you get to very high doses.. is a comperable dose to what was being administered to these rats a very high dose? That I do not know, perhaps there is a study on toxicity of cinnamon), now whether or not you would really want to eat the quantity of it that these rats were subjected to is a different story entirely. I suspect you would not.

I will search for some good cinnamon recipies

It easy to stay healthy some people just don't care 🤷‍♀️

Thank you for commenting and reading, have a great day!

Very interesting article and could provide the information to loose weight by using natural food sources.

Even if it only helped a little tini bit, that is better than 0. :)

It is a good read. Although I am uncertain as to using this to combat obesity. Obesity is also a mindset, so we gotta tackle that instead of saying, eat more cinnamon. I know I am taking a very direct corner there, but I want to say that everything should be done in consideration.

You are right and I am right there with you. I just thought this was a neat study and interesting to read about is all. It's why wrote the title as a question, which we can now answer at the end with... eh probably not (except for mice), BUT this was a neat study! If cinnamon (somehow) could be incorporated as an additional mechanism, as a component of a healthy lifestyle including exercise, and nutritious food, that wouldn't be a bad thing either.

It certainly shows potential to be part of a solution. And the great thing about research / science is that it is open to debate.

thanks for your steem power transfer...resteem and upvote for your...

your article is very useful keep it i vote you

Thanks for reading! Glad you liked it. I hope to keep making good content.

Make more "Pasteis de Nata" (Portuguese) please!

I had to look up what that was. Looks really tasty!

We put lots of cinnamon on top and then eat! =)

good one.... rats have almost the same composition as humans

Thanks, there are a plethora of metabolic differences. All animal model are surprisingly different in their metabolism from humans and from each other. It's quite interesting.

interesting it is... thanks for sharing

And thank you for reading and chatting with me :D

the pleasure is mine... :D

Stop eating sugar and research Ketogenic diet for weight loss.

Thank you for your comment.

Great read! Cinnamon is one of my favorite spices... would put it on nearly everything!

Thanks, yeah it truly is a good one! Quite versatile, adds to a wide range of other flavors and useful in many types of dishes from sweet to savory.

I've used Cinnamon in my morning coffee for past month now and my diabetes sugars have decreased significantly

Not entirely surprising to me:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0003986110002092

It has been reported to improve insulin sensitivity (of course only in an animal model). So its not necessarily correlatable to humans... but still the logical justification is there in the literature.

Interesting read! Thanks for sharing!

Thank you for reading! :D

Very glad you liked the post.