Psychiatry is Practicing Outdated, Fake Medicine

in #psychology7 years ago (edited)

What makes a man tick?

Before psychiatrists classified mental disorders as "depression" or "schizophrenia," ancient witch doctors said crazy people were possessed by evil spirits or invaded by devils. Hippocrates, an early Greek physician, however, said a person fully engorged with black bile suffered from melancholia and was constantly grave and gloomy.

Hippocrates was the first to describe mental sicknesses as having biological roots. He noted four different liquids: phlegm, black bile, yellow bile, and blood. If these liquids were unbalanced, a person would suffer from mental distress or health problems. These liquids were referred to as humors. This Greek idea persisted until medical research of 19th century exploded and modern psychology materialized through the work of Jean Charcot, Anton Mesmer, and Sigmund Freud. However, the idea of chemicals being out of equilibrium in the body never quite died.

shutterstock_272046833 (1)

In a sense, Hippocratic medicine continues to thrive. Hippocrates is the original gangster of the psychiatric medical model. If not for him, psychiatrists would not be so obsessed with chemical balances and imbalances, and checks and balances within the brain and the its electrochemical wiring. Albeit today, even with some scientific knowledge of brain chemicals and chemical-imbalance sicknesses, there are more and more melancholic people. There is more anxiety and craziness. There is more unhappiness and mental disturbance.

Mental Illness and Mental Disability are Growing Despite Claims of Cures


Mental sickness is growing despite the biological remedies being advanced, including psychiatry's pharmacological program to medicate people for their problems. This modern approach to melancholy combined with arrogance of brain circuitry, has incited a more modern sickness: the quick fix through a pill, detached human connections, and the belief the brain is broken.

For example, Robert Whitaker explored this topic in his book, Mad in America: Bad Science, Bad Medicine and the Enduring Mistreatment of the Mentally Ill. He said there has been a 600 percent hike in the total and ongoing disabilities of millions of people taking prescription psychiatric remedies. Furthermore, the pharmaceutical industrial complex is a billion dollar industry, which is steadily increasing as more people get medicated. According to a Scientific American article, 1 in 6 people are on a psychiatric pill.

This implies the medical approach has done little, other than exacerbate the current crisis, setting the stage for more mind sicknesses, distress, and hopeless anxiety. The pills actually appear to activate symptoms that were previously nonexistent, thus causing new sicknesses as a result of the drug's effects on the brain.

For instance, antidepressants appear to cause "tardive dysphoria" when used over the long term. This means they cause the sickness they are meant to cure. Other psychiatric remedies do similar things: they cause more problems the longer a patient takes them. If they do not cause "mental illness," the drugs chemically castrate the patient and flatten their range of emotional expression. All of this is occurring while psychiatry trumpets claims of cures and other pseudo-remedies. In the literature, this is called an iatrogenic effect. This means the doctor harmed the patient.

giphy (2).gif

The Psychiatric Medical Model has Failed; People Will Begin to Wake Up


Biological cures and psychiatric medical model of care has failed. Those in the psychiatric-industrial complex possess rampant egomania. They have been so proud of their war on mental illness---with their pills and powders---but modern science has not even solved the mind-body problem. They have been arrogant. Psychiatrists have little knowledge of how neurochemistry or neuroanatomy effects brain function and leads to "mental illness," yet they have manipulated people's brains with no concern of the disastrous side-effects. Now people should begin to wonder if their arrogance has paid off, or if they have acknowledged the vile nature of their Frankenstein-like experiments.

The situation is reminiscent of the man who learns to drive on an obscure dirt road, but who has never driven in a vast metropolis...someone who finds himself in a complex downtown roadway and is expected to navigate it and understand the terrain while attending speed limits and acknowledging road signs and cars, with only vague knowledge of inner-city travel and road rules.

This is an accurate portrayal of psychiatry's current state of knowledge concerning all the details of neuropathology. They are the inexperienced drivers navigating the infrastructure of the brain. It is catastrophe in the making, and it is precisely why mental illness has not declined. It is why more people get sick and why psychiatrists base their diagnoses off of behavioral checklists rather than objective lab tests or scans.

They are still toying with those early humors. They are living in the past and have not moved forward. They have done nothing except give rise hubris, pride, and more sickness. In this regard, psychiatry is about control. It has been about suppression. It has been about sedation and mental tyranny. If people do not catch on, the real reasons why people suffer will remain ignored. Their humanness will be left for dead on the roadside. Hopefully, in the future, everyone will wake up and realize the damage psychiatry has done and create new institutions that will actually make a positive difference in people's lives.

psychiatry


Sterlin Luxan is a visionary thinker, cryptocurrency junkie, connoisseur of psychology, an MDMA high priest, and the Mr. Rogers of Anarchism. He writes for bitcoin.com, runs a consultancy business in the crypto space, and is a public figure. He created the doctrine of relational anarchism and contributes to many causes in the thriving liberty ecosystem.

sterlin good

Sort:  

If you make your money writing and then following on the effects of the prescriptions you write, every problem will be solved with a new prescription.

Too much focus on managing disease, not enough emphasis on getting to root cause and permanent cures.

Like the post! I've worked many years in psychiatry, and my impression of many psychologist, psychiatrists and other professionals is that they often have "zero" life experience. Like..you could tell them you're on this awesome platform called Steemit, where you make cryptocurrency money and its on a blockchain, in an enthustiastic manner. Make no mistake, these people would immediately check off "schizophrenic" on a post it note :)

Like..you could tell them you're on this awesome platform called Steemit, where you make cryptocurrency money and its on a blockchain, in an enthustiastic manner. Make no mistake, these people would immediately check off "schizophrenic" on a post it note :)

haha this one made me laugh xD

Thanks :) What I mean is that many professionals are too quick to write people off as mentally unstable. You feel anxious? Its a disease!! You're a little bit depressed? Take pills!! You're angry for something? Should we be concerned with you? I feel like something is not right in this society! Hmm..probably schizfophrenic. We diagnose normal states of mind, normal changes in behaviour and mood is looked upon as not normal. Why are so many young boys diagnosed with ADD? Because all the teachers are women now! Everything is characterized from a female perspective. Sure it will affect young boys. But nooooo..they have ADD. Put them on drugs.

I totally agree with the idea that most doctors are too quick to label a mental illness and prescribe a pill for treatment. I think this big problem might stem from doctors focusing more on symptoms rather than the underlying cause of these symptoms.. Someone who might have been feeling unfulfilled working their retail or accounting or security etc job for the past five years may start to be feeling symptoms of depression, but that does not mean they have depression!!!

Good points. Some of those diagnosises are just for selling more drugs by Big Pharma.

This was a great post! I heard a speech by Robert Whitaker last Autumn it was really eye opening. I've always thought that psychiatric drugs can be damaging but I didn't know there was so much evidence for it. One other of the worst is Xanax, or any benzo actually. Used to treat panic attacks and ends up causing them in the long run. Especially if one would ever try to quit using them. They are probably the most horrible psychiatric drug in my opinion.

Antidepressants cause many side effects if taken for long time. Thanks for informative post.

Thanks so much. You are right. Antidepressants and antipsychotics both have a high risk profile over the long term. The evidence is in. It's awful stuff.

Nice you make space for this it is indeed true what you say. I got improsined labeled psychotic and they kept me 7 days in jail, they even nailed me down with emergency medicine against my will with the force of 5 people in a white room where i was locked up. I slowly came out of this and i started to see that they completely lost the way in psychiatry, it is merely a pharmaceutical lobby guiding doctors to apply mental diseases. It is economics in the end sad thing, and not the right treatment for people. I am happy i came out by myself through psychedelic trips i organized by myself, i had a trauma hidden inside, but i overcame it. What psychiatry does is label a single moment how they see someone and they can never understand the reasoning of someone who have an all seeing eye for some time. All seeing in a methaphorical way, the all seeing eye of how your life was built around it before and some pressure you want to break out. I wrote a book about my psychotic episode i called it 'escape the matrix syndrome', and 3 years after i still think the same while i am working on a farm project together with a friend. Don't take the words of the doctors so seriously, listen to yourself and find the right people around you and treatment to heal trauma. In the end we all have a hidden secret inside that sometimes just need to see daylight once , or at leas that is my experience

I almost went to medical school to be a psychiatrist but the current mental health practice is to just substitute the severity of one symptom with a more manageable symptom through pills almost exclusively. This leaves out quite a few tools we have to measure mental health that gives a much more well rounded and data driven perspective of someone's mental health.

Basically to improve overall mental health diagnosis we need to increase access to the tools we have and fund more research into future tools.

I am about to finish med school and become a phychiatrist. And I have to tell you that you can't write pharmaceutical treatments off. Many people have been saved because of them and I have witnessed it. I can't deny there is arrogance governing the actions of some people in profession but don't dismiss phychiatry like that. The tests that check the behavioural patterns are well studies and they do leave subjectivity mostly out of the equation(every doctor in all specialities still has his unique opinion)
Many biochemical tests are also about to take place in the clinical practice just give it some time. I don't agree with some practices that are taking place but black and white in phychiatric diseases and their treatment does not exist there is just too much grey to know before-hand what is right.

I agree that pharmaceutical/chemical treatment plays its part but bottom line an industry that focuses on shareholder value and increases quarterly revenue just like all other industries should not be praised as the only answer to mental illness, whether long-term, chronic, or even short lived psychotic episodes.

I agree with you

This comment has received a 0.13 % upvote from @booster thanks to: @theokritos.

Good information, Thanks for sharing

This comment has received a 0.14 % upvote from @booster thanks to: @hamzaoui.

The knowledge from Hippocrates is unbelievable for me. Hundred of years before Jesus. :O

I don't think antidepressants actually work....I think it's a way to give some sort of affirmation to the patient that he will be fine IF he takes the pills regularly. It's all about what you believe in. There have been cases where medicine has been proved wrong when they write-off a patient's case as can not be healed, but the patient, just because of his sheer determination and faith, has recovered without the help of modern medicine.

What a great post Boss, always informative and educative .. Always on a look out for your post. Resteemed

"You don't have permission to access /blog/mad-in-america/201106/now-antidepressant-induced-chronic-depression-has-name-tardive-dysphoria on this server."
Bummer, I wanted to read that. Great post though, I always found it interesting that almost all mass shooters are on some sort of SSRI or pill. From my own experience experimenting with some of these drugs I can see how they can disassociate the user from reality, causing much worse problems than what is being "treated".

Great post really informative thank you

The problem is the field was dominated by theory. Now they use evidence-based practice and the field is improving, no less since collaboration with neurologists is revealing anatomical and physiological evidence of some of these diagnoses. I read an article earlier this week where it appears psychopaths truly do have different wiring, with an emphasis on immediate rewards rather than the mental time machine/consequence balancing of neurotypicals. Just food for thought.

Very interesting post, good to read, greetings from Poland ;) upvoted of course.

While it have become popular to slander psychiatry for broader societal problems (or the inability to simply just "fix everything"). To me this is just as much of a cultural problem that a problem relating to psychiatry at large. In scandinavia we don't tend to fill people up with pills for no good reason and diagnosis have been discussed a great deal the last couple of years. It is so incredibly easy to just point at something and go "there is the problem". However a bit broader perspective comes a long way to actually fixing the issue - in this case it might be worth looking at the whole American model - hardcore capitalisme, and how this might not be a good option for the individual in the first place. Okay, well that is a bit much to fix at once - maybe we should start a bit smaller, maybe ask, should the health industry even be a industri? It seems a lot more expensive and ineffective compared to other countries with a more social approach.

Psychiatry has become yet another way to peddle big-pharma's "cures".

There are people working overtime to come up with "illnesses" to match the "cures" they've already "discovered."

I'm still waiting for them to come out with the Gummy anti-depressants.

Love reading your stuff.

I like this post. Thanks @sterlinluxan

Some of us have been aware for a while,....

https://stss.nl/

Hey, great post! We have featured your article in our weekend newsletter! Keep up the good work, and let us know if you have any concerns.

Join us on the science-trail Discord

It took you a year since I critiqued your first posts about psychology but you finally got it.

Psychiatry, much like psychology is mostly post-hoc bullshit. Not a science.