You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Psychology Addict # 30 | What Makes a Boy a Boy & a Girl a Girl?

in #psychology7 years ago (edited)

This is a very interesting topic. More so because lately the question of gender and that of transgenders has been figuring prominently in the media igniting an ongoing debate.

Your notes of the behaviors noticed in animals is very revealing because there are quite a few similarities between say monkeys and humans in everything, including behavior. It is worth pondering about the results of experiments conducted using animals and correlating the findings with human behavior and psychology.

So, what do you think? Are boys and girls intrinsically different or are their distinctions a result of culture and gender beliefs?

Gender identity usually comes about in children around age two to three. Once they move past that age they start developing fixed mindsets about gender stereotypes. The main reason is due to gender identity being a biological thing. There are unmistakable biological traits that put humans into either category which are also observed and followed by children. They make their assumptions on the basis of what they see and observe, as well as what they are told or taught.

As far as feelings and other qualities go, it rests on a person's masculinity or on the other hand, femininity. A certain flexibility of gender is being seen in recent years with people identifying themselves either publicly or privately with one gender.

Again going back to the post, playing with dolls or with guns or trucks is defined by preconceived notions that are suggested by a child's observations form the world around them, or from TV or the movies.

But of course your post goes into much more depth with various details derived from scientific studies and experiments which is what makes it so unique and fascinating!

All in all, it doesn’t really matter what makes a boy a boy and a girl a girl.

The statement seems so simplistic but goes to the crux which is that being human is what matters. :-)

Sort:  

Hello my dear @maxabit

Thank you so much for leaving this most beautiful comment!

Let me just highlight here some of the things that you pointed out that I think are particularly important for the other readers too keep in mind:

It is worth pondering about the results of experiments conducted using animals and correlating the findings with human behavior and psychology.

This is very true indeed! :) And, in my opinion, this is also the very reason why it is so useful to study them - the fact that their societies are not as complex as ours! It is almost a paradox! :)

There are unmistakable biological traits that put humans into either category which are also observed and followed by children.

There are unmistakable biological traits that put humans into either category which are also observed and followed by children.

Learning from watching! And this is why I ask myself if the factor that weighs heavier in Camille seeing herself as a girl is the social/environmental one. Even more so when I come across studies such as the hypothalamic response to androstadienone.

Not that one determiner (biological, social or psychological) is more important than the other; and that is why I ended with the sentence you quoted here! You got it :D

Thank you my dear, for always showing so much regard for my work.
It feels very rewarding and motivating :)