Thanks!
To tell you the truth, this was SOOOO long ago. Almost 20 years. I went home through the panhandle and almost immediately got off of the main roads. No location metadata back then so I have no way of even guessing. Let me know if you find it!
Full Disclaimer: OK... my memory was more than a bit foggy. My curiosity got the best of me so I started Googling. Apparently this is in New Mexico and I was completely wrong.
(shhhhhh... no one will know unless they read the comments! )
SPOILER ALERT... don't follow the link unless you actually want to ruin the mystery of what happened in this ghost town.
http://www.rockymountainprofiles.com/Folsom%20NM.html