Wow. Thanks for all the responses on this. I have 100% up-voted all the responses (for what thats worth !) . I love the darker versions that have been cropped into more of a pano format. I am going to split the prize as there was a few that I like. @aweber comes in at first place prize of 1 SBD as he edited the shot in a way which was closest to how the experience felt to me when I took the shot. Also I like the edits of @vmoldo and @kevinleedrum so they take consolation prize's of 0.5SBD each. Thanks again for everyone edits ! It has provided some inspiration for me to take another look at this shot. As for the the best 'photostar' edit; I have to go with the radical edit by @derekkind!