Caught out: The toxic culture in Australian cricket that led to the ball tampering scandal

THE toxic culture in Australian cricket that culminated in the shameful ball-tampering cheating scandal and tarnished the game has been exposed by high-profile former cricket players, coaches, executives and commentators.

In a new documentary, ‘Caught Out’ — which aired on the ABC on Monday night — several industry insiders claimed Australian cricket’s “win-at-all costs” culture has been intensifying for years and was destined to implode.

According to them, the mass exodus of legendary players; a winning streak that suddenly turned into a losing streak; a reputation for being “a pack of dogs” who “played too hard”; and the pressure in which the players were under to turn it all around, led to some bad decisions.

The worst among them, ball-tampering — which has seen captain Steve Smith, vice-captain David Warner and player Cameron Bancroft suspended for 12 months.

But one question that has plagued sports fans since the scandal unfolded is: why did they risk it?

In early March this year, Warner avoided a ban over his infamous staircase stoush with Quinton de Kock in Durban, but his level-two charge came with a heavy fine and three demerit points. It meant Warner was essentially on his final warning for the next two years, with even a minor misdeed to trigger an automatic suspension.

The fracas was sparked by disparaging remarks about Warner’s wife Candice.

According to Cricket commentator Jim Maxwell, “a siege mentality seemed to have overtaken the side after that incident”.

Smith publicly backed Warner on March 8 as the team prepared for the second and ill-fated Test against South Africa.

“Davey plays well when he’s aggressive and he gets into a contest,” Smith said.

“He has to be careful not to cross the line. Sometimes you can go over the line and that’s not what we want to see.

“I can’t promise it’s not going to happen again in the future.

“But we’ll be doing our best to ensure our behaviour’s in a good place.”

They were fighting words that would come back to haunt them as the ball-tampering cheating scandal — which Smith and Warner were at the centre of — started to play out around the world soon after.

“A lack of maturity of the leadership and the narrowness of their approach to the game, particularly in dealing with their emotions, made sure there would be an error of judgment, that unfortunately, came to pass,” Maxwell said.

Maxwell says the plan to ball tamper was devised during the lunch break of day three.

“Warner (was) trying to pass on responsibility to look after the cricket ball to the younger player (Bancroft). Almost press ganging him into doing what he needed to do to the ball,” Maxwell said.

“And Steve Smith overheard what was going on and says ‘what are you blokes up to? I don’t want to know’. And that’s when he should have jumped in and been more vigilant.”

Steve Smith (L), then-captain of Australia and teammate David Warner (R) wait to start the day’s play during day one of the second cricket Test match between New Zealand and Australia at Hagley Park in Christchurch on February 20, 2016. Picture: AFP / Marty Melville.
Steve Smith (L), then-captain of Australia and teammate David Warner (R) wait to start the day’s play during day one of the second cricket Test match between New Zealand and Australia at Hagley Park in Christchurch on February 20, 2016. Picture: AFP / Marty Melville.Source:AFP

Cricket Australia has confirmed one year bans for Steve Smith (L) and David Warner (R) following revelations concerning ball-tampering. Picture: AFP / Marco Longari.
Cricket Australia has confirmed one year bans for Steve Smith (L) and David Warner (R) following revelations concerning ball-tampering. Picture: AFP / Marco Longari.Source:AFP

WINNERS BECOME LOSERS

But the pressure on the team had been mounting long before then.

In November 2016, Australia had just lost its fifth consecutive Test match, this time in Hobart against South Africa, whose captain, Faf du Plessis, ironically, was later charged with ball tampering. Cricket Australia head honchos James Sutherland and Pat Howard marched into the change rooms after the game and declared that something would have to change.

From then on, Smith and coach Darren Lehmann would run the team their way.

A hard-fought tour of India followed in early 2017 but it was pockmarked with rancour, accusations of cheating and on-field confrontations.

There were soon whispers of leadership issues that were preventing the team from overcoming conflict and coming out on top.

According to BBC cricket commentator Alison Mitchell, “David Warner’s a stronger personality than Steve Smith, and Steve Smith may be not able to question things maybe that David Warner was saying”.

Critics claimed that although Smith was arguably the best batsman in the world, he lacked leadership ability, and was often overpowered by Warner — who was once known as “the Bull”.

Ms Mitchell said Smith’s managerial and leadership skills didn’t compare to past Australian captains including Don Bradman, Bill Woodfull, Warwick Armstrong and Richie Benaud.

Iconic cricketer Merv Hughes told the program that “Steve Smith is a quieter, more gentle sort of a soul, Davy Warner is the bull in the China shop”.

“He’s going to break a few things along the way,” Hughes said.

Cricket writer and author Gideon Haigh said there was a tendency to “always ... choose the best player in the side rather than necessarily a player with alleged leadership and management attributes”.

“Everyone looks to you in times of crisis,” Haigh said.

“You’re the first person who gets the blame when the team fails. You’re also the one who’s built up the most grandly. And the kudos that comes with being the captain is disproportionate.

“I don’t think people quite understand how great an honour it is.”

Haigh said Smith was “prepared by God for modern cricket” but that he had instead “actually ended up becoming a bit of a victim of it”.

And there’s one place everyone should be looking more closely at, according to union representatives.

Australian Cricketers’ Association president Greg Dyer said “culture comes from the top ... it doesn’t come from the bottom”.

EXODUS OF LEGENDARY PLAYERS

Former Test player Bryce McGain told the ABC a mass exodus of cricket legends — including Matthew Hayden, Adam Gilchrist, Justin Langer, Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath — had left a gaping hole in the game.

“They had this team of outstanding and unbelievable cricketers who were once-in-a-generation cricketers, but there was about five or six of them in the one team,” McGain said.

Former Australia cricket captain Adam Gilchrist speaks to the media during an Ashes media event at the Gabba in Brisbane, Wednesday, October 18, 2017. Picture: AAP /Albert Perez.
Former Australia cricket captain Adam Gilchrist speaks to the media during an Ashes media event at the Gabba in Brisbane, Wednesday, October 18, 2017. Picture: AAP /Albert Perez.Source:AAP

The Australian team, which was long renowned for its winning streak, suddenly became acquainted with losing. It was amid this transition that Smith stepped into Michael Clarke’s shoes as captain and Warner became vice-captain.

“Having that same mental disintegration with a group of players that aren’t quite at that elite level requires a different approach,” McGain said.

“I haven’t really seen an enormous change in the way we go about it, but it’s always very publicly said, we need to play aggressive, we need to push the line, we need to play in that manner to be successful. Times may have changed.”

But even then, it wasn’t anything new.

John Buchanan, coach of the Australian team from 1999 to 2007, described an “ugly scene” in which legendary player Glenn McGrath was filmed aggressively standing over a much smaller Indian player who had sledged him, contributing to the “concept we were good winners but poor losers”. But he said the desperation recently seen among Australian cricketers “comes about by pressure”.

“Spirit and rules of the game can be pushed to the limit,” Buchanan said.

“That pressure has driven them to a decision that will change a lot of cricketers’ careers and will change the attitude, unfortunately, of many people in the Australian public how they view Australian cricket.”

Former Australia cricket captain Michael Clarke. Picture Channel 9
Former Australia cricket captain Michael Clarke. Picture Channel 9Source:Channel 9

Cricket Australia (CA) will learn whether it faces a judicial stoush over suspensions handed down to the shamed trio of Smith, Warner and Bancroft on April 11.

Hearings over the level-three charges and/or sanctions issued to Smith, Warner and Bancroft are expected to take place — if needed — on Wednesday week. There remains a possibility the trio will cop their whack and CA will put a full stop to the ball-tampering saga that has already cost the governing body millions in sponsorship and affected TV rights negotiations. However, it’s fading fast.

Warner is understood to be particularly keen to put his case to an independent code-of-conduct commissioner.

Smith and Bancroft have also sought legal advice and are strongly considering challenging their bans, which were for 12 months and nine months respectively. CA’s code of conduct dictates that players can accept sanctions at any point “prior to the commencement of the hearing at the time/place specified in the notice of charge”, which is understood to be April 11.

Former Australian cricket captain Steve Smith breaks down as he speaks to the media in Sydney, Thursday, March 29, 2018, after being sent home from South Africa following a ball tampering scandal. Picture: AP/Steve Christo.
Former Australian cricket captain Steve Smith breaks down as he speaks to the media in Sydney, Thursday, March 29, 2018, after being sent home from South Africa following a ball tampering scandal. Picture: AP/Steve Christo.Source:AP

The trio has been banned from international and domestic cricket, but encouraged to play club cricket.

There are concerns from the camps of Warner and Smith the star duo could miss out on lucrative national contracts for two years, meaning the effective punishment is more than what CA intended.

There is a sense among many in Australian cricket circles that the bans were too harsh given the International Cricket Council’s maximum punishment for ball tampering is a one-Test ban.

Some members of the Test XI hold that view. Tim Paine is doing his best to lead a distraught group in the fourth Test against South Africa.

“You’ve got some of your best players not in the side, it’s just about people picking up the slack,” Paine told reporters after day three. CA has made it clear its sanctions aren’t for ball tampering, rather conduct “contrary to the spirit of the game”,”unbecoming of a representative”, that “could be harmful to the interests of cricket and/or ... brought the game of cricket into disrepute”.

Former Australia national cricket team vice-captain David Warner during a press conference at the offices of Cricket NSW, Sydney, Saturday, March 31, 2018. Picture: AAP/Ben Rushton.
Former Australia national cricket team vice-captain David Warner during a press conference at the offices of Cricket NSW, Sydney, Saturday, March 31, 2018. Picture: AAP/Ben Rushton.Source:AAP

The CA code of conduct spells out that if a player disputes either a charge or sanction then there will be a hearing before a CA commissioner. If players are unhappy with the verdict at the initial hearing, they have seven days to lodge a formal appeal and take the case to an appeals commissioner. “If they do to take that to appeal, that’s a good, proper legal process,” CA chief executive James Sutherland said last week.

“As a course of natural justice under our code, players have the right.” Sutherland admitted a range of penalties, including some more and less severe, were discussed by CA’s board.

CA’s code of conduct notes that “any decision made by the appeals commissioner ... shall be the full, final and complete disposition of the matter and will be binding on all parties”.

megan.palin@news.com.au | @Megan_Palin

— With wires

Steve Smith (L), then captain of Australia and teammate David Warner (R) wait to start the days play during day one of the second cricket Test match between New Zealand and Australia at the Hagley Park in Christchurch on February 20, 2016. Picture: AFP / Marty Melville.Source:AFP

Share on FacebookShare via SMSShare on WhatsAppShare via Email
Add your comment to this story
Show Comments
read next

‘Absolutely gutted’: Kiwis defy Poms
ENGLAND’s disastrous summer took one final hit when they failed to topple a gallant New Zealand lower-order.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

Live: Warne doubts Paine captaincy
CRICKET legend Shane Warne doesn’t believe Australia’s new captain will be able to handle the burden of the role.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

Waugh makes a huge statement
TEST selector Mark Waugh has taken an emphatic stance on Australia’s ball-tampering trio, in a clear sign for their future.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

‘Abusive and self-righteous’: The dark side of Australian cricket
MICHAEL Vaughan has taken aim at the behaviour of the Australian cricket team and refuses to believe this is the first time ball-tampering has happened under Steve Smith’s captaincy.

AUSTRALIA

ACA wants bans reduced for trio
THE “extraordinary” responses by Australia’s ball-tampering trio should be factored into their bans, the cricketer’s union says.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

ACA wants bans reduced for Cape Town trio
THE Australian Cricketers’ Association has called on Cricket Australia to take into account ‘extraordinary contrition’ shown by Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft over the ball-tampering scandal.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

The Warners’ secret classy act
AWAY from the cameras, David and Candice Warner aren’t the people you would expect — as one secret act of class made clear.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

Old habits will die hard: Proteas not convinced
SOUTH Africa opener Dean Elgar has questioned whether Australia can continue their charm offensive, noting ‘nice guys come second’ and verbal spats are ‘human nature’.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

Australia’s charm offensive won’t last: Elgar
AUSTRALIA has turned a new leaf under captain Tim Paine, cutting out the sledging as they look to win back the support of the public. South African opener Dean Elgar does not think it will last.

AUSTRALIA

Roxy hits back at Warner reports
AS REPORTS emerge David Warner could lock in a $1m tell-all, Roxy Jacenko has smacked down claims she’s behind the lucrative damage control campaign.

CRICKET NEWS AND GALLERIES

Steve Smith will redeem himself, but David Warner is done
Steve Smith will redeem himself, but David Warner is done
Problem with Warner’s confession
Problem with Warner’s confession
Teammate fuels Smith conspiracy theory
Teammate fuels Smith conspiracy theory
Candice fires up over star’s claim
Candice fires up over star’s claim
Disgusted Waugh’s perfect reply
Disgusted Waugh’s perfect reply
‘Remarkable’ text shows Bancroft’s class
‘Remarkable’ text shows Bancroft’s class
Candice: ‘It’s my fault and it’s killing me’
Candice: ‘It’s my fault and it’s killing me’
UFC chaos after shattering bombshell
UFC chaos after shattering bombshell
Players want ‘rogue’ Warner gone
Players want ‘rogue’ Warner gone
Australia’s hypocritical David Warner stance
Australia’s hypocritical David Warner stance
Recommended by

Newsletters
Follow us
A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content (including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and content more relevant to you on our network and other sites.Find out more about our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out.