Excellent reply ...
Some bullet points in response to your reply :
Where did you get the 40 % number from ?
The rich / more fortunate taking from the poor / those who have less has been happening since the dawn of time and won't stop.
Agreed about placing " Promoted " content ( which should include any article / post that has paid for votes on it ) in the " Promoted " section. Another way is to have an Organic Posts section that list all post with 0 paid for votes on them.
I never said the human bots that don't upvote bad content didn't accept the bid money. I can't speak for all but I have seen some that will not only not upvote a post but will also keep your funds and possibly flag you as well.
There are a few different types of voting bots, @steembasicincome is just another type. It's purpose and how it functions doesn't change what it is. Don't get me wrong its a great initiative but its still a voting bot.
No matter what system is in place people will find a way to take advantage.
Thanks for the reply.
The 40% number: one of the witnesses did a detailed data scrape last month that included all sorts of information including bot income—I’ll see if I can find it.
Yeah, people have been stealing from other since forever. Does that mean we should enable them and give them the money they need to do it? How is that logically any different than shrugging your shoulders and saying that people are going to phish and hack each other and then giving them the tools to do it?
No need in finding the article .. I was just curious as to where the number came from.
I wouldn't call what some bidbot owners are doing stealing. They offer a service, seeing value in your purchase or not is up to the individual using the service. Plus Its like anything else. You need to educate yourself before using / spending your hard earned money on.
A person willingly uses a bot ... no-one willingly gets hacked or joins a phishing scam.
Here's the post I was thinking of. I messed up the number but it's still pretty bad (I suck at remembering numbers--will edit my previous comment so as not to mislead any readers going forward). Over 30% of curation rewards go to bots; over 25% of all SBD earned goes to them, and over 10% of all earnings total go to bots. If you think about that, it's a HUGE amount of money, enough that if any one of those bidbot owners decided to cash out and go retire in Costa Rica tomorrow, they could crash the price of STEEM easily. It also means that all of that money is being taken out of the reward pool the rest of us share.
I think they're stealing from all of the users of the site by hoarding the reward pool. Sure, the people that "feed" them with SBD/STEEM are doing it willingly, but the rest of us are not. We're so quick to come down on haejin for "stealing" from the reward pool (I object to the use of the term "reward pool rape," which people like to do) but what he's doing is causing a minuscule fraction of the damage that the bots are to the internal economy. And they're doing it knowing that it's cheating newbies out of what little money they make.
Those numbers are interesting. Looks like Steemit works the same as funds in the real world work. The ones at the top have the majority.
The only problem I have with hajin upvoting himself constantly is that ( from what I seen ) he only upvotes himself / upvotes others very little. But ultimately that is his choice to make.
The way I look at it is .. he invested and is currently reaping the rewards of his investment. He is free to do so just like anyone who wants to flag him is also free to do so.
As for taking money out of the reward pool, that is what we are all here to do. We didn't invest to just keep our funds on Steemit forever. We want a return on our money / time. And as you said .. the reward pool belongs to everyone so each individual gets to decide what to do with their share of it.
And that takes me back to the bid-bots. I don't view it as stealing. When you pay for a good and receive that good or service it isn't theft. The buyer gets a return on their purchase. Didn't like the return ? Don't use the service again .. just like you would do in other aspects of your life.
I should clarify that I’m not trying to act holier than thou and say my moral compass is better than anyone’s. I’m not a bidbot owner so I’ve never been in their shoes. I acknowledge that it’s easier for me to criticize them when I’m not the one making the decision. On the flip side, it’s not in their interest to do what’s best for the site, so they can’t be relied on to make ethical judgments either.
You weren't coming off that way and I hope I am not either. Nothing wrong with a healthy debate / discussion.
I am on the fence about bid-bots. Remove them completely or join in seems to be where my opinion on them is headed. Admittingly I still have some research to do before I form a complete opinion on the matter.