The dog fights were absolutely amazing! In fact, all of the visuals and sound were.

I enjoy both types of war movies that you mentioned (individual stories as well as nature of war). For me, it just depends on the movie. I personally would have enjoyed this one more if it focused on the individuals. But I can see why others (including my wife) strongly disagree with me. I really wanted that huge emotional payoff when the civilian boats arrived. But war isn't like that. It was my fault for having a predetermined expectation walking in. I think if I had never seen any previews or knew very little of the story, I would have enjoyed it more. (Although perhaps "enjoy" is the wrong word.)