I also have read this ... and I dont wanna sound like a smart ass ... but if either of those debating God have read Pascal
s Pesnsees :
http://www.ntslibrary.com/PDF%20Books/Blaise%20Pascal%20Pensees.pdf
or Platons "The Cave" witch even has a short animation on
Youtube
these are things easy to understand ... then you could have a real debate ... conversation there are many more I could of mentioned but these i found to be my starting point of contemplation ...
I haven't read Pascal Pesnsees so I can't speak about that, but I have looked into Plato's allegory of the cave before.
I totally agree with the allegory. But it can use against any kind of argument brought up by anyone.
So on and so forth.
Anyway, thanks for getting involved in the conversation!