My money was on the Scottish brew from the start, only to find out it was an IPA vs a Stout. That's not much of a fair fight, in my opinion. For me, the Stout would win 9 times out of 10, even in the summer sun. Obviously, I'm quite biased about that. ;)
Haha, you know I have to agree with you! I couldnt find two good stouts to go head to head with one another :O)
I actually was more looking forward to the mexicake one I had the other week which I bought as well. Its flipping magic!