Yesterday was an interesting day with the attack on Steemit.com.
But I believe it had a very positive side effect.
A lot of people were taught a little bit more about what a blockchain is.
With Steemit.com (website) being down a lot of users realized that busy.org was still up and running. (albeit had trouble logging into busy.org, I could still browse the website) and chainbb was fine too.
That's because Steemit and the Steem blockchain are not the same things.
Steemit is a website that taps into the Steem blockchain and pulls out data and shows it in a way that we are all familiar with.
Busy.org and Chainbb do the same thing and portray the same data in another format.
So yesterday, the blockchain was not attacked but the website Steemit.com was.
The data was therefore safe.
The Steem blockchain is kept alive by Witnesses and the cool thing is they (top 20) get paid from the same reward pool as you and me for doing this job. But it's an important job because without them, no blockchain.
At least that's what I think.
I realized that while making my blog I'm not 100% sure if that's even true.
What would actually be needed to bring down the Steem blockchain? Is it even possible?
If a witness could answer this question I would be very grateful.
Bitcoin SwC Poker, download and use affiliate code: Blazin8888
Great explanation for how the block chain works and how someone could attack the front end and not harm the actual block chain. This has taught me a lot about block chains in general and it's quite fascinating. It seems this is a subject I really enjoy and love learning about. While crypto currency I find fascinating b/c of it's utility and the good it can bring the world, I never really took the time to understand exactly how a block chain works. Really cool stuff. I didn't even think about why I could get on Esteem and not steemit.com, it makes perfect sense now.
Understanding how this works now, I don't know why every business in the world wouldn't want to be on a block chain. It seems much more secure and would give customers multiple avenues to conduct business while one of multiple front ends were under siege.
Great questions and look forward to the answers you get from some witnesses regarding this. Have a great workout brother and a great day!!
For hackers it is virtually impossible to bring down a blockchain unless the source code is badly written. However if 51% of the witnesses collaborate (or one witness gets 51% of the power) to attack/tamper with the blockchain there will be serious problems. Does this mean that the blockchain is down then? No, but it won't be very useful any more because the 51% attack could steal all funds from the users. Is this likely to happen? No, because the steemblockchain uses delegated proof of stake so they can loose their stake (which is 51%) when caught with tampering. If the source code of the blockchain is badly written and expose a backdoor to attack a witness (or all witnesses at once!) a single hacker could tamper with the data (move funds etc) what will make the blockchain die eventually unless the changes made by the hackers are reverted (aka what ethereum did after the DAO attack).
I don't think the steem blockchain can be brought down, but it can be slowed down. A DDOS is basically supposed to slow down websites by adding load to the servers. The servers then shut down automatically or manually because of the over load.
The blockchain itself, can be similarly over loaded. Remember what happened to Bitcoin a few months ago? Thousands of unconfirmed transactions, high fees etc. STEEM can face the same thing but is better prepared because of the role of witnesses.
Coming to a consensus is much easier on STEEM, if the block sizes have to increase for the network to run smoothly, witnesses can do so and an average of their declared sizes will be used. That's how witnesses had solved the bandwidth issue on the steem blockchain two months ago.
DDOS not only slow down, if servers can't handle the load it might open holes to the DB section!@sqamemal,
Cheers~
What's really important are our Seed Nodes. The more we have and the more distributed they are the better. I was just wondering about how distributed our network was last week and actually investigated it and did up a report which you can find here.
We're currently not very well distributed with most nodes sitting in France, Germany and the US. Even with this type of consolidation all three countries would have to target those nodes at the same time to bring the Steem blockchain down. If they did we'd only have a few scattered nodes around the other countries that the whole network would be relying on. Likelihood of this happening is extremely low, but it'd be nice to see our blockchain network branch out and grow some more.
Oh yeah, we all were nervous yesterday with this attack, but thank God everything went well. I think it's almost impossible to hack blockchain, if only you have copied the secret keys, then you can hack everything. Conclusion: take care of secret keys! Thank you @exyle
This is always good advice!
for me its not possible as i think its a decentralized network running in a lot of nodes...
when it went off... i mean the site... i got info through eSteem and updated my post from chainbb and busy.org was ok for me then... which made me know its ddos attack and i updated my post to assuage nerves from my followers... nice one sir... always good post coming from you@exyle
@exyle I was never worried at all after viewing @jerrybanfield posting today. In fact it was nice to learn about Busy.org and Chainbb......
They been around for a while but still a little bit unknown to many it seems.
I think bringing down a blockchain is very unprovable unless there is some critical bug in the code.
Steemit is more vulnerable to attacks, maybe in a future sites like Steemit will be hosted in Maidsafe network so ddos attacks will not work.
The bitcoin protocol is according to the general opinion, extremely on. It is almost unassailable, however, as soon as we leave the network, and we are dealing with machines or humans that have the famous private keys that manage the transactions bitcoin, there are risks . And today we do not yet have the full measure of the means to implement to ensure the safety of the users facing these risks.
nice post @exyle, DDos attack is not good and i think peoples do this because to harm the reputation of the website but steemit is rock solid and i am sure no body harm it with their silly thinkings, well no doubt that with that downtime we came to know about busy.org and chainbb and that's great if the steemit.com is down we can actually use it on alternative website and yesterday we do the same and it's actually a very good experience to us, you ask a question how can somebody stop the blockchain and bring it down and yes it's also good knowledge for us if any witness share his experience with us, enjoy your workout my friend and have a very cheerful weekend ahead, thanks for sharing.
There is NO way, to bring down the blockchain. Period. Steemit on the other hand is total different story. It would be nice to see some theory, who was behind the attack.
I don't think it's possible to bring down the blockchain, we'll have to see what @dragosroua has to say about this :)
Dear friends, I will follow you all the time and vote for me Pleasure me Follow me and vote I will be lending to you '
Hahaha, the incident yesterday made some people panicked, but after I explain can use app eSteem finally they are relieved. @exyle
Dear friends, I will follow you all the time and vote for me Pleasure me Follow me and vote I will be lending to you '
"What would be needed to bring down the blockchain?"
A moon-sized meteor. Or another thing to destroy the earth. That would bring it down.
All other attempts will fail, because there simply are too many backup witnesses to step in when others go down.
Thank you Satoshi for introducing decentralization!
I actually thought that the websiteb was down due to some major updates that might had to implement. Didn’t know about busy.org or chain bb, will definitely use them from now onwards.
The longer I am here the more I am learning about each of the roles of the witnesses and just how awesome blockchain is and how it works.
Not having a great understanding of it all nor having loads of time to just research each area of it has slowed me down but nuggets of gold being shared is amping up the knowledge.
Thank You for being just one of those with the nuggets being shared.
I just knew for the first time that steemit and steem blockchain are different. Thanks for sharing.
Following the incident of yesterday, I would also like to know what is needed to bring down and shut steemit blockchain.
I really hope we get to read from a witness soon.
Thanks for starting this discussion mate!
Knowing about other front ends is cool. I hit the blockchain from steemnow.com so I knew all was well. But i was still impatient to hit steemit.com
Am I glad I can vote and comment normally again ^^ When something like this happens you realize how "for granted" Steemit is :P
"A lot of people were taught a little bit more about what a blockchain is."
Yeah, yesterday was a great example of understanding how STEEMIT works on STEEM block chain! I think people who tried DDOS also understand the power of this amazing blck chain just after they failed what they want to archive! Great post again dude!@exyle,
Cheers~
"Steemit is a website that taps into the Steem blockchain and pulls out data and shows it in a way that we are all familiar with. Busy.org and Chainbb do the same thing and portray the same data in another format." ... that is great to remember b/c a lot of noobs like me believe the illusion and think there is something sacred about what we see on Steemit. It's good to remember it's just one way of portraying the information, and that there are many ways to access it and depict it. Like you say, great learning experience !
@exyle - Sir, a good question. I also have the same question & hope one of the top witness will answer us here Sir. Love the work you did Sir <3
+W+ [ReSteemed & UpVoted]
i am know anything on this yet but it would be cool to see the answers coming from professionals
To bring down the Blockchain, the code that was rightened must have a flaw or bug. Even the 51% attack has not been proved to take down the blockchain.
I was very glad to hear that the blockchain wasnt affected!
The End Of The Blockchain Bull?
Dear friends, I will follow you all the time and vote for me Pleasure me Follow me and vote I will be lending to you '
Steemit Forever,
Why you told yesterday was interesting day to you after attack on steemit.com?
Maybe i can agree with you. But sometimes cannot. I know that i am really addict to steemit. Thank you for sharing your idea with us.
Have a good day!!!
I think it's just a figure of speech. It was an interesting day because it was different from normal.
click here.Congratulations @exyle, this post is the seventh most rewarded post (based on pending payouts) in the last 12 hours written by a Superhero or Legend account holder (accounts hold greater than 100 Mega Vests). The total number of posts by Superhero and Legend account holders during this period was 21 and the total pending payments to posts in these categories was $1186.54. To see the full list of highest paid posts across all accounts categories,
If you do not wish to receive these messages in future, please reply stop to this comment.
I 100% agree with you sir. However we are very luckily here our data was safe..
Thank you for your post.
Following and upvote
again unshaven?
tHE DAY WAS PRETTY INTENSE but nevertheless it was worth it
The belief people had on steemit it became more as soon it got back up on the site .
Hope everything goes well and on ;)
Dear friends, I will follow you all the time and vote for me Pleasure me Follow me and vote I will be lending to you '
I believe the blockchain will fail if all the witness simultaneously decided to sabotage it, please correct me if i am wrong.
Blockchain the most secure ledger of all time ever Crypto's the best invention since the wheel, good luck with that hackers and government. Cheer$;)
I don't think there's any other way than to pass a New World Order against it, lol.
Long live steem!
Uneasy when Steemit was down . With everything so crazy in today's hacking world it is good to know that the blockchain has so many protections.
I'm not sure exactly what would it take. I think all Steem seed nodes would have to be DDOS at least all of them used by witnesses. The seeds provide the state of the blockchain (latest blocks) to the witnesses. I think DDOS the witnesses would be more tricky though I'm not sure. I think RPC nodes would have to be DDOS too.
I'm not an expert on these kind of things.
A list of some of the public seed nodes.
https://status.steemnodes.com/
yes!!!
Would one compromised witness be enough?
lol, o man @ezzy if you ever needed content for a book.