is anarchocapitalism and christianity compatible?
Searching the web
58 results
Yes, anarcho-capitalism and Christianity are compatible, according to many libertarian Christians, scholars, and thinkers, though the question is debated and depends on interpretations of Scripture.Arguments in FavorProponents argue that anarcho-capitalism aligns with Christian principles of free will, private property, non-aggression, and voluntary cooperation:God grants humans free will and dominion over creation (e.g., Genesis), which supports self-ownership and voluntary exchange rather than coercive state authority.
Private property is biblically affirmed (e.g., Thou shalt not steal in Exodus 20 implies ownership), and markets allow peaceful, charitable interactions without force.
Figures like Murray Rothbard (agnostic but influential), Lew Rockwell (Catholic), Tom Woods (Catholic), and Norman Horn (founder of Libertarian Christian Institute) defend anarcho-capitalism as consistent with Christianity.
Hans-Hermann Hoppe (non-Christian) praises traditional Christianity, especially Catholicism, for preserving Western values like property rights and culture.
Romans 13 (calling for submission to authorities) is reinterpreted by some as applying to any legitimate governance (including private property owners or voluntary associations) or as descriptive of God's use of states for judgment, not prescriptive endorsement of the state itself.
Christian anarcho-capitalists emphasize that the state often violates Christian ethics (e.g., through war, theft via taxation), while a stateless society enables true charity and justice.
Communities like r/christian_ancaps and sites like LibertarianChristians.com actively promote this synthesis.Arguments AgainstCritics contend they are incompatible:Romans 13 and other passages (e.g., "render unto Caesar") seem to endorse state authority as God-ordained, making outright rejection of government sinful.
Christianity's emphasis on caring for the poor and communal sharing (e.g., Acts 2–4) clashes with unregulated capitalism, which some see as fostering greed or inequality.
God's sovereignty is viewed as the ultimate "authority," making human anarchy hypocritical if it rejects all rulers.
Traditional Christian anarchism (e.g., Tolstoy, Dorothy Day's Catholic Worker Movement) is typically left-leaning and anti-capitalist, rejecting private property hierarchies.
Some denominations (e.g., certain Reformed or Catholic views) see the state as necessary for common good and order.
Overall AssessmentWhile mainstream Christianity often supports limited government rather than anarchy, a significant strand of evangelical, Catholic, and libertarian Christians affirms compatibility, viewing anarcho-capitalism as the most consistent application of non-aggression and biblical liberty. The debate hinges on biblical exegesis, particularly Romans 13, and views on property/charity. No universal consensus exists, but it's far from inherently contradictory.