You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Real Life Story #10: The dilemma with Islam and its culture in a nutshell

in #islam7 years ago

I helped in the first place by stopping him. I helped further by offering her and her children asylum if she needs it. I helped him by explaining to him how we feel about his behaviour and telling him, that we will not tolerate it in future.

As the man was more concerned about embarrassing me with noise instead of asking his wife for forgiveness combined with her feeling being justly treated I see there a cultural problem.
(it would lead to nothing if I reported him to police, if SHE would not speak out as a witness)

My reason to write this post was to share my observation and my belief that this is a cultural problem, mainly justified by another interpretation than yours of the quran.

No idea why you try to put me in a position to justify my doings instead of coming up with solutions/ideas other than interpretations of overrated books.

Sort:  

Your observation is nothing but an attack on Islam and some 1.6 billion Muslims, if it wasn't, then why would you include a pic of the Quran in your post?. What kind of a solution were you looking for through steemit?... Just do the right thing next time and report him to the police... or is Germany a lawless country?.

I attack any idea, that spreads a totalitarian system. My observation isn't an attack, but just that: an observation And my conclusion is based on a strong correlation and tried justifications such as yours. You say this affects 1,6 billion people... great, the more people are involved, the more important it gets to speak out. Or do you believe that a wrong cause gets less immoral because of more people taking part in it?
It is funny that you keep talking about the police. This indeed would have been a possibility, still I dismiss this as a less good option compared to what I have done (especially with concerns for her and not him). What this has to do with Germany or a land being lawless, I don't really understand.

You seem to be Muslim, so tell me, do you think that Sharia Law should be implemented worldwide? Has this to do with your question about Germany possibly being "lawless"?

Why are you bringing up sharia law?... Is it not a crime in Germany to beat a woman?... Or do you not have faith in the German criminal justice system?.

There is a big difference in something being right, just or legal. I truely do not have much faith in the German criminal justice system. As I explained earlier, calling the police in this situation would have made the womans life even more miserable.

I bring up sharia law because you keep insisting that I should have called the police. I want to know what your culture is. So I ask again:
Are you muslim? And if so, do you think that sharia law would be the best punishment possible for any crimes described there? Please answer this straight or just stop talking, else you will make yourself implausible...