With the Tempora Mutantur the artist did a good job "copying" the photo that's sure
Honestly I can't like either that rounds, I mean that's not even abstract art where you can try and guess... I can't see why depressing should resemble depression or give you depression...
My pick here : Blue Field
You picked a nice one and I think those watercolors are the winner this time. The rest is for a particular taste and not mine either.