
As I rushed my mother to the hospital that night it was a replay of many crises in her lifetime. She had been in and out of hospitals for years. Once, before I was born, my mother came so close to death that she believed she'd seen God, and that he had welcomed her.
I feared this crisis would be her last. When the doctor offered a chance at life I grabbed it. The man was a partner to her regular physician, so I trusted his recommendation.
"Let me try something. Let me ventilate her and see if it works," the doctor offered.
My mother was a whisper away from death. The stark choice was to listen to this man, or never bring my mother home. The thought that she would die, right there in front of me, was unbearable.
"Yes." I gave my permission.
Oh, the price of ignorance. Only afterwards did I realize that a ventilator was actually a respirator. This was a word I recognized, respirator. And I knew my mother was absolutely determined that she never be kept alive 'on machines'. It would have been bad enough if I paid the price for my grave ignorance, but it was my mother who had to pay.
The respirator 'worked'. It performed the task my mother's weary lungs could no longer manage, and I was horrified. She was pinned to the machine. The moment she woke and realized she was imprisoned, she shook her head, No! No! Her eyes were wide and panicked.
I demanded she be freed. I thought ventilation was a temporary measure, a transitory intervention. The doctor told me he could not legally remove the machine unless my mother was able to breathe on her own. He had trapped her, and me. Or so he thought.
My battle began at that moment. I called in experts to evaluate her case. The prognosis was always the same. Her lungs were destroyed and she was not able to breathe independently.
My campaign intensified. I went to the hospital administrator and began a complaint process with outside agencies. I gave the doctor who ventilated her a new name: 'Dr. Frankenstein'. Everyone in the hospital, from physicians, to nurses, to administrators, was aware of my accusations, and my crusade to free my mother from the machine.
Meanwhile my mother was desperate. The nurses told me what the future would be if she couldn't get off the ventilator. She would be placed in a ward with other patients, who were lined up like subjects in a grotesque experiment. These patients lay all day long with machines pumping air into them, while technicians periodically siphoned fluid from their lungs. This was the sentence, until they died. Meanwhile, the doctor and hospital reaped great financial rewards each day the ventilated patients lingered.
I had done this. It was my mistake, my desperation that had put my mother in a waking nightmare.
Finally I called so many outside resources, and made such a fuss, that it attracted attention. The partner of "Dr. Frankenstein" appeared at the hospital. His first words were, "What is all the noise about?"
I told him I wanted my mother off the ventilator. He repeated the grim conditions for release 'Dr. Frankenstein' had explained, but he also expressed a determination to help us. He would try to improve my mother's health so she could be weaned from the machine, and after that discharged as soon as possible from the hospital. There would be a narrow window of opportunity. If her lung capacity declined, she would be ventilated again.
The year was 1985. Hospice didn't exist. Living wills were evolving. The hospital and doctor held all the cards. A lengthy legal battle might resolve in my mother's favor, but she would not live long enough to reap the benefits of that decision.
We never left her alone, my sister and I. One of us stayed with her in the day. Another spent the night. A cousin, who loved her dearly, took a 'shift' to give us respite from our vigil. The moment arrived when the new doctor thought my mother was strong enough to breathe on her own. He removed the ventilator tube from her throat. There was a period of acute anxiety as we waited to see if she could breathe. She did.
My mother was released from the hospital on September 30, 1985. The expectation was that she would die within a few hours, or days, at most. She defied all expectations and survived until January 23, 1986. In that time, she was home, with her family. She ate Italian delicacies she loved and saw her grandchildren every day.
We enlisted a licensed practical nurse, respiratory therapists, oxygen machines, and nebulizers to assist with my mother's care. The doctor who had helped us in the hospital visited several times to check on her, but still we lived in a state of apprehension. What would we do if she went into crisis? Could we handle it? The week before she died she asked, "How will I die?"
I passed the question along to her doctor. He explained that he had seen few pleasant deaths. Often, with this condition, there was a struggle, because the patients drowned in fluids from their lungs.
The night of her death my sister and I prayed with my mother, as we did every night. We knew the end was close, but had no way of knowing how close. My mother fell asleep in the middle of a prayer, with the Rosary in her hand. My sister slept on the floor next to her bed.
In the morning, my mother was gone. She hadn't moved. None of the suffering the doctor described was evident. She was smiling. Maybe God greeted her, as she believed he had done before. Perhaps he opened his arms and gave her the welcome we all hope to receive when we have taken our last breath.

Illustration Credits, from LIL, the LMAC Gallery of images:
Bird
Sunset
Abstract Design
@yaziris
@muelli
@justclickindiva
That's the best one can hope for to anyone in such situation.
At least you gave her that.
I'd definitely do what you did if I was in a similar situation. Doctors are good, doctors can help, but they're not right 100% of the time.
We hear all the time about people that were given an estimate of a couple more months to live, and they lived for much much longer.
Very touching story @agmoore ❤
Thank you so much, my friend.
And that is enough. We are all going to die, we hope later rather than sooner. The best we can hope for is a good death. She had that.
This doctor was not ethical (the one who ventilated her). He was known for putting people on that machine and no matter what we said or did he refused to try and wean her off. It obviously could be done, because it was done.
I very much appreciate your comment. Hope you are well, @yaziris
Hello @agmoore. I was absolutely floored when I first began to read your story. I thought you looked at the history of my Profile and found the telling of my mother's struggle with the family at not being placed on a ventilator. It was a heartbreaking read. My case went in a different direction from your mother's, but the outcome was the same.
I felt you. I felt her firm stance. I felt the family. It was all there as though it happened last week when I relived the saga on her anniversary.
I felt.
Thank you for including me fractal in your story. The spinning out of control of the situation and the issue that had to be addressed was twirling in my thoughts while reading.
You told my mother's story in excellence. She watched (Dr. Marcus Welby, M.D.) then told me never hook her up to a machine to keep her alive. I honored her wish.
I appreciate you sharing your mother's story. Take care and have a good rest of your week.
!ALIVE
!LADY
There was no picture that could express the sense and emotion of this piece. Your fractals came to mind, because they are so gentle and so emotive. Thank you for that.Dear @justclickindiva,
I wrote this partly because I know the issue is universal. Those of us who are lucky have mothers. Those of us who are very lucky have good mothers. It is hard when care of that good mother falls to us, when their well-being becomes our responsibility. You have been through it, and it echos with you because the experience is intense.
I hope this wasn't upsetting to read. I also hope it might help people who find themselves in a similar circumstance. The laws are better now, but the choices we need to make are not.
Thank you very much for that response. It means a lot to me that you related to it and shared your experience.
Take care of yourself, @justclickindiva
AG
No, it was not upsetting. Thanks so much for your concern. As you know, time heals the sharpness, but going through the experience is an episode in your life you'll never forget. You feel as if you're in a maze. And you are correct that decades ago, the laws were vague and resources scarce. Having to make a decision without adequate understanding of the consequences is devastating.
Take care.
View or trade
LOH
tokens.@justclickindiva, you successfully shared 0.1000 LOH with @agmoore and you earned 0.1000 LOH as tips. (1/13 calls)
Use !LADY command to share LOH! More details available in this post.
You Are Alive so I just staked 0.1 $ALIVE(2/10)@agmoore! to your account on behalf of @justclickindiva.
The tip has been paid for by the We Are Alive Tribe
through the earnings on @alive.chat, feel free to swing by our daily chat any time you want.
At least she was at peace. It must've been so painful to lose her. I commend your strength at that difficult time. Thank you for sharing your story.
She was very much at peace. Quite a religious woman, so religious it was contagious. It was painful to lose her, but she helped us. She made a conscious decision to help us accept what was coming. Always thought about us before herself.Hello @olu45,
Thank you very much for your insight and your comment.
Your mother died at home with family, which is as much as any of us can hope for. It's a shame that it had to be such a harrowing experience to accomplish this and you'd wonder, in the case of the first doctor, whatever happened to 'first, do no wrong'. It seems that too many forget, particularly when ministering to the elderly, that no matter his age, to each his life is precious.
In the end she just wanted to be with her children. We were fortunate that one doctor helped to make it happen.
I appreciate the comment and insight. Life is precious. That seems to be the one thing we share with every other creature on earth--something you well know as you rescue animals, human and otherwise :)
I cannot imagine how desperate you must’ve been during your mother’s suffering. The medical fraternity, for all its dedication to scientific innovation, can be cruel because of their unwavering belief in their code to preserve life; not the quality of life, only life. Of course it’s a fatal flaw in the system, that makes for many horrifying experiences.
Your experience was brutal, but it seems that the heavens shone mercy on your mother (and on you) and you were able to give her comfort and show her your heart in those final days. What an absolute blessing. 💕🤗💕❤️
Thank you very much for reading my post and commenting. I know you are close to your mother and can relate to this battle. You are right. The fight was brutal. An interesting, poignant aspect to those last months is that my mother told my sister at some point she was ready to go, but I wasn't ready to let her go. She hung on for me, so I could prepare myself. Those months did make a difference. She and I were so different, but in those months we came to a peace. In the end, I was as ready as anyone can be for such a loss.
Now that's a mother ♥️
Hope your mother is well and that you are enjoying her every day. Take care, @itsostylish
May her soul rest in peace
This is well scripted
That question that threw everyone in silence and unspoken anguish, "HOW WOULD I DIE."
that touched me the most.
We know it's inevitable yet, we do not know how to address it
Thank you for that moving, lovely comment. Yes, I was impressed in those last days by my mother's courage. Her nephew had told her a few years before that she was showing us, the younger generation, how to grow old gracefully. In those last days my mother was showing me and everyone else how to meet our end with grace.
I hope you have a wonderful evening and that peace is with you, @jjmusa2004
Yes, thank you
This is a story of love and courage, @agmoore! What seemed natural and the safest thing to do became a mistake that contradicted your mother's wish about her way of deciding about her life, even in her last moments. It takes a lot of emotional intelligence and a lot of courage to make the kind of claims that you and your sister found it necessary to make to fulfill your mother's wish. Bravo to her family! We appreciate this testimony in which a life ends with a smile that keeps faith and hope in those who are still alive. Thank you for writing, @agmoore.
Hello friend and former colleague, @gracielaacevedo. You write eloquently not only of my blog but of the way all of us have to deal with final life issues.
What a mistake. When I saw the prompt it called to me. But that mistake gave me months to come to a peaceful resolution in my relationship with my mother. That was gift from her to me, her last but not her greatest gift.
Thank you so much for your insight and kind words. Have a most wonderful week.
They will all be together again in eternity. The reading gripped me. It was an intense read, trying to reverse a decision that, although it seemed the right one, condemned a loved one to live tied to a respirator.
The way you described his departure leaves a little bit of relief in our hearts.
Thank you very much for your kind comment. The material seemed a bit personal, but then what value does writing (or art) have unless it touches us personally? We all lose loved ones and must come to terms with that. It is really as universal as a theme can be.
Have a great weekend, @innfauno12
I can say that your story touched the fibers of my soul. My mother also went through a similar situation, she was about to die, but thank God she still has more time with us. We always thank life for this second chance.
It hurts that your mother is no longer with you, but at least she is in a better place and her smile after she died confirms it.
Thank you for sharing this emotional story.
Good day.
I am happy your mother has recovered from her illness. Second chances gives us time to come to peace with each other, if that has not happened yet.
Thank you for your kind words. Yes, we did take comfort in that smile. There was so much worry about how the end would be. We were blessed with the way it transpired.
Enjoy your mother every day. I hope her health continues to hold up and you have many more years with her.
Warm regards,
AG
Thanks for your kind words.
a wonderful day!
It is a text that moved me very much. I could almost feel the despair at the beginning and then that final resignation. No matter how much we are told that we must prepare for death, we will never be prepared for it, and even less so with the death of the mother. I congratulate you, you managed with your writing and your story to remind me of my dead father. Greetings and thank you for sharing your experience with us.
Thank you very much for your kind comment. If we are lucky enough to have good parents, their loss will always be painful. I hope the memory of your father's death was not upsetting. I hesitated to be as specific as I was, but I also wanted to be honest.
We are human, and sometimes we feel alone with profound feelings. Writing can help us to form a connection with others and to perhaps find comfort in that.
I appreciate your comment and hope you have a peaceful evening.
What happened to Doctor Frankenstein 😭😂😂
I guessed that name is a side effect of when a literature obsessed individual gets mad and thinks of something unique 😂😂😂
I'm so happy your mom had a peaceful death.
It's so hard to come by nowadays 🙂
May she rest in peace 🕊️
He was around, and a threat we always felt.
Thank you very much, @seki1. Your kind words are much appreciated.
Can never trust Frankenstein 😓
It is quite painful
I know how crazy the death of a mother can be. She fought hard but still lost the life she was fighting for.
I hope she rests in the most perfect peace. I wish you a happy Easter
in most perfect peace. Have a wonderful Easter.Thank you, @rafzat. I appreciate very much your kind and sensitive response. I think she does rest