The Giants' Draft Dilemma: Focusing on Mid-Round Quarterback Prospects
As the New York Giants gear up for the season finale against the Philadelphia Eagles, there's a prevailing concern regarding the team's position in the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft. Sitting at pick number four, the Giants may find themselves out of range for the two top quarterback prospects, Cam Ward and Shador Sanders, who are expected to be selected within the first three picks. This situation has sparked discussions around potential mid-round quarterback prospects, particularly Alabama's Jalen Milroe and Ole Miss's Jackson Dart.
Jalen Milroe has garnered attention as a potential second-round pick, being referred to as a project quarterback reminiscent of Philadelphia's Jalen Hurts. NFL draft analyst Matt Miller highlighted Milroe's upside but noted his inconsistency as a passer. He had a mixed season at Alabama, showcasing his elite dual-threat capabilities with 20 rushing touchdowns but also struggling with passing accuracy, throwing 16 touchdown passes to 11 interceptions.
Milroe's potential lies in his raw athleticism; he possesses a unique blend of speed, clocking in at a remarkable 4.3 seconds in the 40-yard dash. This ability to run has become increasingly valuable in today's NFL, where the traditional pocket passer is becoming less common. Comparisons have been drawn between him and quarterbacks like Josh Allen and Jalen Hurts, both of whom had points in their careers where they significantly improved under proper coaching.
Brian Daboll, the Giants' head coach, has coaching ties to Alabama, having previously worked with Hurts. If retained, Daboll could potentially see parallels between Milroe and Hurts, making a case for the Giants to invest in Milroe despite his passing inconsistencies. In this predictive analysis, if the Giants do not secure a top quarterback and Milroe is available in the second round, he could be a worthwhile project for the organization.
In contrast to Milroe, Jackson Dart has gained traction as a compelling candidate for the Giants. Dart's skill set is marked by exceptional accuracy and sound mechanics. Standing at 6'2" and around 230 pounds, he showcased a standout season at Ole Miss, finishing with a completion rate of 69.3%, 4,279 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, and just six interceptions. These numbers led the ACC and reflected Dart's capability as a playmaker.
Scouts have noted Dart's ability to deliver the ball downfield accurately—a skill that is sometimes overlooked in modern quarterback play. His mechanics enable him to make tight-window throws with poise and under pressure, which is essential for success at the NFL level. Dart’s capacity to connect seamlessly with speedy receivers could greatly enhance any offensive scheme. This high mechanical floor positions him as an intriguing prospect, standing out among mid-round quarterbacks.
Dart's impressive final collegiate season may see him rising up draft boards, possibly even into the second round. If the Giants are looking at mid-round options, Dart brings promise as a quarterback who can develop into a reliable starter, provided he has the right support system.
The crucial question for the Giants will be their approach this offseason. If they do not manage to lock in a franchise quarterback early on, they might need to rely on one of these mid-round talents. Both Milroe and Dart present intriguing possibilities: Milroe as a high-upside developmental prospect with elite physical traits, and Dart as a technically proficient quarterback capable of immediate contributions.
As the postseason and draft scouting progress, how the Giants perform in terms of coaching decisions, especially regarding quarterback development, will ultimately determine the success of whoever they choose. Building a supportive environment around whichever quarterback they opt for—be it Milroe, Dart, or another prospect—will be integral to their long-term success.
The current draft landscape is filled with uncertainties, but engaging with emerging quarterback prospects will give Giants fans some hope. As offseason evaluations ramp up, both Milroe and Dart will likely remain at the forefront of discussions as potential solutions for the Giants' future quarterback quandary.
Engaging in this cycle of speculating and analyzing mid-round prospects prepares the Giants and their fanbase for various draft scenarios, ensuring they are ready for whatever direction their front office may choose.
As the draft date approaches, opinion shifts may occur, but one thing remains constant: robust discussions surrounding quarterback prospects will continue to inhabit the Giants' narrative.
Part 1/9:
The Giants' Draft Dilemma: Focusing on Mid-Round Quarterback Prospects
As the New York Giants gear up for the season finale against the Philadelphia Eagles, there's a prevailing concern regarding the team's position in the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft. Sitting at pick number four, the Giants may find themselves out of range for the two top quarterback prospects, Cam Ward and Shador Sanders, who are expected to be selected within the first three picks. This situation has sparked discussions around potential mid-round quarterback prospects, particularly Alabama's Jalen Milroe and Ole Miss's Jackson Dart.
Jalen Milroe: The Dual-Threat Project
Part 2/9:
Jalen Milroe has garnered attention as a potential second-round pick, being referred to as a project quarterback reminiscent of Philadelphia's Jalen Hurts. NFL draft analyst Matt Miller highlighted Milroe's upside but noted his inconsistency as a passer. He had a mixed season at Alabama, showcasing his elite dual-threat capabilities with 20 rushing touchdowns but also struggling with passing accuracy, throwing 16 touchdown passes to 11 interceptions.
Part 3/9:
Milroe's potential lies in his raw athleticism; he possesses a unique blend of speed, clocking in at a remarkable 4.3 seconds in the 40-yard dash. This ability to run has become increasingly valuable in today's NFL, where the traditional pocket passer is becoming less common. Comparisons have been drawn between him and quarterbacks like Josh Allen and Jalen Hurts, both of whom had points in their careers where they significantly improved under proper coaching.
Part 4/9:
Brian Daboll, the Giants' head coach, has coaching ties to Alabama, having previously worked with Hurts. If retained, Daboll could potentially see parallels between Milroe and Hurts, making a case for the Giants to invest in Milroe despite his passing inconsistencies. In this predictive analysis, if the Giants do not secure a top quarterback and Milroe is available in the second round, he could be a worthwhile project for the organization.
Jackson Dart: The Accurate Passer
Part 5/9:
In contrast to Milroe, Jackson Dart has gained traction as a compelling candidate for the Giants. Dart's skill set is marked by exceptional accuracy and sound mechanics. Standing at 6'2" and around 230 pounds, he showcased a standout season at Ole Miss, finishing with a completion rate of 69.3%, 4,279 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, and just six interceptions. These numbers led the ACC and reflected Dart's capability as a playmaker.
Part 6/9:
Scouts have noted Dart's ability to deliver the ball downfield accurately—a skill that is sometimes overlooked in modern quarterback play. His mechanics enable him to make tight-window throws with poise and under pressure, which is essential for success at the NFL level. Dart’s capacity to connect seamlessly with speedy receivers could greatly enhance any offensive scheme. This high mechanical floor positions him as an intriguing prospect, standing out among mid-round quarterbacks.
Dart's impressive final collegiate season may see him rising up draft boards, possibly even into the second round. If the Giants are looking at mid-round options, Dart brings promise as a quarterback who can develop into a reliable starter, provided he has the right support system.
Part 7/9:
The Future of the Giants’ Quarterback Position
The crucial question for the Giants will be their approach this offseason. If they do not manage to lock in a franchise quarterback early on, they might need to rely on one of these mid-round talents. Both Milroe and Dart present intriguing possibilities: Milroe as a high-upside developmental prospect with elite physical traits, and Dart as a technically proficient quarterback capable of immediate contributions.
Part 8/9:
As the postseason and draft scouting progress, how the Giants perform in terms of coaching decisions, especially regarding quarterback development, will ultimately determine the success of whoever they choose. Building a supportive environment around whichever quarterback they opt for—be it Milroe, Dart, or another prospect—will be integral to their long-term success.
The current draft landscape is filled with uncertainties, but engaging with emerging quarterback prospects will give Giants fans some hope. As offseason evaluations ramp up, both Milroe and Dart will likely remain at the forefront of discussions as potential solutions for the Giants' future quarterback quandary.
Part 9/9:
Engaging in this cycle of speculating and analyzing mid-round prospects prepares the Giants and their fanbase for various draft scenarios, ensuring they are ready for whatever direction their front office may choose.
As the draft date approaches, opinion shifts may occur, but one thing remains constant: robust discussions surrounding quarterback prospects will continue to inhabit the Giants' narrative.