Part 10/12:
Many felt that James Gunn, renowned for his humor and ensemble comedy, struggled to adapt his style to a solo superhero film. The result was a tone that swung wildly, from earnest to irreverent, without settling into a consistent voice. The visuals appeared hurriedly assembled, with some calling the editing “hastily done,” and the score was described as uninspired and generic.
The film’s messaging, which attempted to frame Superman as a beacon of hope and virtue, was perceived as superficial, lacking reverence or depth. Superman was relegated to a series of setbacks and frustrations, culminating in him being handed more moments of exasperation rather than triumph.