Part 6/12:

James Gunn’s approach to Superman aimed to revisit the character’s Golden Age roots—embracing color, optimism, and classic heroism. The film, however, faced scrutiny for its execution, tone, and storytelling choices. Critics expressed disappointment that the narrative didn’t focus solely on Superman himself, but instead, involved a plethora of characters and subplots that muddled the story.

Concerns about tone over correction were palpable. Instead of capturing the earnest spirit associated with Superman—akin to John Williams’ iconic theme or Christopher Reeve’s portrayal—the film felt disjointed, oscillating between serious moments and tonal shifts that resembled the style of Black Adam and other darker DC entries.