Part 4/7:

Penn State’s trajectory is a familiar one: perennial performers achieving records like 10-2 yet failing to meet the expectations set against top-tier opponents. Finebaum argues that the playoff format seems tailored for teams like Penn State, who repeatedly fall short in pivotal games. The current season, including an encounter against ranked teams, only emphasized their ongoing challenges.

Despite gaining entry into the playoffs, critics deem their achievements as a result of a 'luckier' schedule featuring teams like SMU and Boise State, lacking convincing wins. A recurring theme emerges: James Franklin's inability to secure significant victories against high-ranking opponents. Some believe his coaching style needs re-evaluation if he wishes to lead the team to true greatness.