Part 3/6:

Critics have been quick to voice their disdain for this rule, describing it as unnecessary and reminiscent of gimmicks rather than traditional baseball. Suggestions have been made jokingly that if you're going to apply such whimsical rules, why not go even further? Perhaps implement Rock, Paper, Scissors in extra innings or even hold a dance-off between players. The very premise evokes laughter but highlights a grave concern: this rule could reduce baseball to mere exhibition material.

Many baseball purists argue that the unpredictability of which player steps up in crucial moments is what makes the game magical. The potential for a non-star to become a postseason hero adds to the sport’s allure. Those moments can become legendary, weaving themselves into the fabric of baseball history.