Part 4/5:

To finish, fresh butter is scattered on top, allowing it to melt into the warm pie, enriching every bite with a rich, creamy textural element. This method ensures that each portion delivers a complex mixture of pumpkin, apple, and a hint of herbs, showcasing the diverse palette of flavors that characterized the era’s cuisine.

A Historical Culinary Experience

While this historic pumpkin pie may not align with the expectations of modern Thanksgiving guests, it represents an opportunity to travel back in time and experience how our ancestors enjoyed this seasonal squash. The combination of flavors and preparation techniques reflects a culinary landscape that was adventurous and diverse, contrasting sharply with the standardized pumpkin spice profiles that dominate today’s culinary scene.