Part 4/7:

The Complexity of Age

Though it seems contradictory that both characters can claim to be the "oldest," the understanding lies in how one views their ages. Gandalf implies that the age of Barbárvore signifies ancientness among the native creatures of Middle-earth, a means of demonstrating reverence to the Ents' connection to the land—a deeper, intrinsic value that is not simply based on linear time.

Tom Bombadil, however, belongs to a category beyond mere identification with Middle-earth's native creatures; his essence hints at a unique origin—potentially as an Ainur, hence labeled as an “original spirit.” The uncertainty surrounding his true nature, whether he is an avatar of Eru Ilúvatar or another cosmic being, raises critical inquiries into his role and essence.