Part 6/7:

Additionally, Gandalf wields the Elven ring Narya, which grants him resistance against domination and despair— advantages that Saruman lacks due to his moral decline. Not to mention the legendary sword Glamdring, which was forged with magical runes and has proven itself superior in combat. Saruman’s own attempts at using power would likely falter should he be stripped of his staff or face the full force of the Balrog.

The Hypothetical Nature of the Debate

While the argument against Saruman’s victory resonates, it remains speculative. There exists no definitive answer to who would prevail in a face-off. Each perspective relies heavily on interpretations and deductions influenced by the characters' deeds and motivations established in Tolkien's lore.