Part 4/8:

As the conversation progressed, there was a consensus that while Barkley's contributions to his team are undeniable, it is difficult to argue that he is more valuable than several standout quarterbacks, particularly this season. The trio of quarterbacks—Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Joe Burrow—have been performing at extraordinary levels, each demonstrating their critical value to their respective teams.

Analysts noted that even if Barkley breaks rushing records, it remains a challenge to argue for his MVP candidacy when quarterbacks are setting their own milestones. The impact of a quarterback on the game's structure makes it hard to elevate a running back to the same status, even considering the fundamental contributions such as exceptional rushing yards and highlight-reel plays.