Part 4/7:

One aspect that often gets critical attention in adaptations is loyalty to the original material. Although the hosts have not yet read Dumas' novel, they note that some viewers suggest this version stays more faithful to the source material than its 2002 counterpart. They express a desire to read the novel soon to draw more informed comparisons.

The Hero's Journey

As with the original story, this adaptation follows a classic hero's journey of revenge and redemption. The hosts highlight the moral complexity of Edmond Dantès’ character—his struggles, choices, and ultimate path. They discuss how, while the journey is compelling, they felt that Edmond's character was overshadowed in this adaptation compared to the 2002 film, leading to a less impactful portrayal of his turmoil.