Part 4/8:

While some pundits, such as Mauro César Pereira, argue that this farewell tarnished his idol status, many fans disagree. For them, Gabigol remains a timeless idol due to key contributions, especially his three decisive goals in Libertadores finals—a feat that continues to resonate with the Flamengo faithful. The emotional memories tied to his performances effectively solidify his status regardless of recent controversies.

The Idol versus the Legend Debate

The conversation shifted to whether Gabigol should be regarded as a legend. While he himself dubbed his farewell as a milestone marking his immortality in Flamengo's history, some commentators feel this claim overreaches. To them, true legends—like Zico or Pele—occupy a different echelon in the football world.