This sounds a lot like my paternal grandparents house - spooky central! So to answer your question,yes I would have stayed, since it would be just more of the same for me...lol!

Great Halloween story, Nina and I think it's extra cool your aunt did some digging to figure out who might be behind the haunting. And as much as I enjoyed your story, I have to say my favorite part was your gorgeously scary moon behind the tree photo at the end - beautifully atmospheric capture!