The Web3 Disconnect
Web3 gaming thrives on the idea that players can participate meaningfully without constant paywalls. Whether it’s earning assets through gameplay or enjoying the experience with no upfront cost, web3 games promise freedom of choice. By making payment a requirement for even basic participation, Soulkeep is abandoning this core value.
Imagine if popular web2 games like Fortnite required players to pay for each match. The backlash would be immense, as it places unnecessary barriers on player engagement. Even energy-based systems in mobile games, while occasionally frustrating, offer a middle ground that doesn’t alienate the player base entirely.
Battling Bots but Hurting Players
The rationale behind this move—to combat bots and multi-account exploitation—may seem valid at first glance. Bots can disrupt the economy and skew the player experience, and multi-accounting often diminishes fairness in competitive environments. However, targeting these challenges by introducing mandatory payments is like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut—it solves one problem while creating a host of others.
Players who have supported Soulkeep from the beginning, pouring resources into the game, now face the frustrating reality of being locked out unless they pay. It’s a decision that feels like a betrayal of the community’s trust.
The Impact on Player Activity
It doesn’t take a crystal ball to predict the outcome of this update: a significant drop in activity. For many players, including myself, this new model is a dealbreaker. I’ll be joining others on the sidelines in protest, watching as the game’s vibrancy likely dwindles. Without a player base to populate matches and create an ecosystem, what future does Soulkeep have?
Finding Better Solutions
Combatting bots and maintaining a fair gaming environment are critical goals, but they must be achieved without alienating the community. Here are a few alternative approaches Soulkeep could consider:
Energy Systems: Introduce a capped energy system that regenerates over time. Players can use premium currency for extra matches, but free access remains viable.
Verification Tiers: Implement human verification systems or tiered access that rewards legitimate players without requiring payment but SPS staking instead.
Engage the Community: Work collaboratively with the player base to crowdsource solutions. The Splinterlands community has always been resourceful and innovative when given the chance.
A Call for Change
Soulkeep’s decision is a misstep, but it’s not irreversible. I hope the developers take this feedback to heart and reconsider how they approach these challenges. Web3 gaming is at its best when it empowers players, not when it locks them out.
For now, I’ll be watching from the sidelines, hoping for a course correction that aligns with the values that drew us to web3 gaming in the first place. Soulkeep has potential, but it must honor the community that helped build it.
Discord: @newageinv
Chat with me on Telegram: @NewAgeInv
Follow me on Twitter: @NAICrypto
The following are Affiliate or Referral links to communities and services that I am a part of and use often. Signing up through them would reward me for my effort in attracting users to them:
Start your collection of Splinterlands today at my referral link
Expand your blogging and engagement and earn in more cryptocurrencies with Publish0x! Sign up here!
My go to exchange is Coinbase; get bonuses for signing up!
The future of the internet is here with Unstoppable Domains! Sign up for your own crypto domain and see mine in construction at newageinv.crypto!
Always open to donations!
ETH: newageinv.eth
BTC/LTC/MATIC: newageinv.crypto
Disclosure: Please note that for the creation of these blog posts, I have utilized the assistance of ChatGPT, an AI language model developed by OpenAI. While I provide the initial idea and concept, the draft generated by ChatGPT serves as a foundation that I then refine to match my writing style and ensure that the content reflects my own opinions and perspectives. The use of ChatGPT has been instrumental in streamlining the content creation process, while maintaining the authenticity and originality of my voice.
DISCLAIMER: The information discussed here is intended to enable the community to know my opinions and discuss them. It is not intended as and does not constitute investment advice or legal or tax advice or an offer to sell any asset to any person or a solicitation of any person of any offer to purchase any asset. The information here should not be construed as any endorsement, recommendation or sponsorship of any company or asset by me. There are inherent risks in relying on, using or retrieving any information found here, and I urge you to make sure you understand these risks before relying on, using or retrieving any information here. You should evaluate the information made available here, and you should seek the advice of professionals, as appropriate, to evaluate any opinion, advice, product, service or other information; I do not guarantee the suitability or potential value of any particular investment or information source. I may invest or otherwise hold an interest in these assets that may be discussed here.
Now they just need at ban bots in Splinterlands... entirely.