I think overall this is an improvement BUT point #2 is a terrible decision. 6% is far too insufficient a reward to those who win. (Same with 2nd and 3rd numbers). The old numbers were just fine, it gave everyone something to strive for. Having now had some guild brawls with these new numbers (and being in a level 2 guild arena who are consistently top 3 for brawls) they do not reward well enough.