You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: HBO's, The Penguin: A Review

in CineTV6 days ago

I don't understand why some critics think their review of a series is valid after seeing just an episode. It's like judging a court case on one testimony when there are plenty to consider. But I digress!

Your review is brilliant and an interesting read! I hoped to see a 'good guy' character mentioned here but I see the focus is on villainy and pursuit of power. Oswald and Sofia are fascinating characters and their contrast makes for an interesting study of villainy. Oswald seems a disturbed character with mental illness, and his distorted world view is shaped by his upbringing. On the question of a lesser evil, I think it's Sofia and if I watched this series, I might root for her. But I like Colin Farrell and his Irish accent! 😄

A well-written and refreshing review. I hope you had a relaxing holiday. I wish you a wonderful and prosperous 2025.✨
!PIMP

Sort:  

Thank you very much, dear @kemmyb! You are kind. I wasn't sure anyone would read this very long review :)

I love doing analysis...it's really a self-indulgent approach to review. When a show is this good, this intelligent, I can't resist looking at it in cultural context.

After I read your comment I tried to think of a 'good' character. I guess they exist, but they are so minor that they are irrelevant. It is a dark, dark show--as was The Batman movie that gave rise to this series.

I hope your holiday was enjoyed with family and friends. And I wish for you the most productive, peaceful, healthy 2025 (I really wasn't sure we'd make it here--I feel like a winner 🌟)

Your deep analysis of the characters is what makes this interesting to read. I think the absence of 'good' characters in this series is refreshing, a departure from the norm in films, allowing focus on moral ambiguity. I hope I find the time to see this series soon.

I had a lovely holiday, thank you! And yes, you are a winner for making it here. We are winners! 😄


Your comment is upvoted by Topcomment
image.png

You can support the Topcomment initiative by delegating HP
| 10 HP | 25 HP | 50 HP | 100 HP | 250 HP | 500 HP | 1000 HP |