True that, there is a huge oversimplification on people's ideologies nowadays, either in the left or in the right. I can respect some of the takes of a right wing person about communism or socialism, even if I disagree with him. A traditional person can be reactionary that doesn't mean it's necessarily bad.
Manichaeism is everywhere.
You are right. And when you don't identify with any of the classifications, they classify you as "logicals".