CIME, lol. I don't think it makes you a bad person. I like that you have respect for others with different opinions. And your path in life is your path, and nobody else has any right to judge it. It may be that there are other more important areas for you to address.
I like to think all of us are trying to be the best person we can be, even if we fail over and over. Don't think I'm claiming to be some kind of saint. I don't always manage to be non-judgmental, especially if someone is wantonly cruel.