English Version Of This Article Written By @rivalhw!
The "secret" in "The Moonlight Commentary"
Yesterday, after the publication of “The Final Winner List of the 9th Period Excellent Works of the “Monthly Review””, a small partner and WeChat asked me how the final winner list of the “Monthly Review” was determined. Let us give you a detailed explanation of this article today.
The “Monthly Review” has come from August last year. In fact, the rules of the campaign have been continuously improving and improving. They were selected from the initial jury selection, and then the public voted to the later added judges to score each time, and the judges that we started in the previous period were recommended first. Finally, the public vote and the judges scored at the same time. . . It is believed that the small partners who have been involved in or pay attention to the “New Moonlight Review” are already familiar with it. I will not repeat it here, but I will focus on the winning selection process.
From the beginning of the previous period, that is, in May, our rule is to recommend articles by teachers of the judging panel once a week, every Friday evening, once every month, and then followed by public voting to ensure more In fairness, the voting time will last approximately one week. At the same time, on the day before the end of the voting, we will also aggregate the scores of the judges’ teachers and calculate the average value. This will ensure that the scores of the works will be more assured. objective.
Then, we will count the number of public votes, which is now one point for each vote, and add them to the corresponding works of the previous rating team to get the final score of the work, and then rank them according to the score.
Because we currently have two awards: Literature Award and Art Award, the rankings are also calculated separately. That is, the top three individuals in the literature and arts are selected as the selection prize. The highest score in the group is the current period. Best Excellence Award.
In order to make everyone see more intuitive and clearer, we now take a screenshot of our rating “secret” and see it at a glance.
Of course, we also know that any rule will inevitably have its shortcomings. The “Monthly Review” selection mechanism is no exception, but we also believe that it is the best we currently think because we have always improved and continuously improved the rules. .
Thanks again to all the small partners who support and participate in the "Monthly Review!" Of course, we are very grateful to our judges teachers!