Sort:  

Shake shake shake, you roll the 6-sided die.

You rolled a 5.

5 + 1 (dagger) + 1 (ingot) + 1 (class/stage rule) = 8. @what-is-life needs to just roll to accept and complete the challenge.

Challenge accepted @rollthedice

Shake shake shake, you roll the 6-sided die.

You rolled a 6.

6 + 1 (1st dagger) + 1 (2nd dagger) + 1 (ingot) - 3 (gem) = 6.

bunny fluff maintains life total as the defender.
Setzer maintains life total as the victorious attacker.
Setzer loots a dagger dagger from bunny fluff.

Setzer's new inventory: dagger x2, ingot
bunny fluff's new inventory: dagger, ingot, gem

Setzer challenges bunny fluff a 2nd time, this time for the bunny's gem.

@rollthedice

Shake shake shake, you roll the 6-sided die.

You rolled a 6.

6 + 1 (1st dagger) + 1 (2nd dagger) + 1 (ingot) + 1 (stage/class rule) = 10. Awaiting challenge acceptance and dice roll from @what-is-life .