Has Bitcoin Forked up?

in #bitcoin7 years ago

If Btc forks on august the 1st then Bitcoin is dead! ... Think about it! Both chains will no longer be the original bitcoin as one will be bitcoin cash with a bigger block size from 1 mb up to 8 mb and the other will have a code update to segwitx2 ... Neither will be the original bitcoin anymore ... After August the 1st Bitcoin could be battling against alt coins but this time around be an altcoin itself ... What do people feel about this? i myself want bitcoin not another over priced altcoin :( ...

Please comment and discuss your feelings and share my post ..

Sort:  

If you put it like this, then you already don't have the original bitcoin, as there have been various (minor or major) code changes to bitcoin since 2009!

like what? .. i know coins have forked out of bitcoin .. what code changes has happened to bitcoin and when?

I can't list them for your, because there have been 170+ releases of Bitcoin Core, (what you perceive currently as "original"). See them here, and you can check the release notes for each and every version available.

Apart from the 2000+ closed issues in bitcoin core's github, you can see all the BIPs (Bitcoin Improvement Proposals), some of which have been implemented (either partly or in full) here.

You can't expect a piece of software to stay the same for that long, no matter how big/small, popular/unpopular it is. If it's being used, it changes. It's been 8 years since bitcoin started. Even Microsoft's Windows has major changes (a.k.a. Service Packs, or more recently "Updates" [in the vein of "Creator's Update" etc]) within the same version.

Bitcoin's Github repository has, while writing this, 14,597 commits (each commit may fix a bug or insert a new feature, or remove a deprecated feature, or a combination of them -among others, this is an oversimplified list-)

So, in that way, the "original" bitcoin doesn't exist, since a long time ago. There have been at least 13 public major releases (0.2 being the first I can find in the repository linked above, and 0.14 being the current) that bring new functionality, many more bugfixes (0.14.2 is the current) and even more release candidates, which are what we call "almost ready for production" packages.

Segwit2 is an improvement proposal from the current bitcoin team (Bitcoin Core, aka "official client"), and Bitcoin Cash (the "unofficial fork") was trying to push some other changes. The result is that the community is now split in 2, and that's why the fork will happen tomorrow. They both are direct descendants from the "original" bitcoin, which stopped existing since v0.2 (and we now are on v0.14).

I'm sorry I wrote such a big comment. It was either this or no comment at all. I don't like half-assing information.

I'm linking for you here, the release notes from v0.14.2, scroll down to "0.14.2 Change log" (located about half-way), and read the changes for the second revision of v0.14.

thanks for the reply :) .. i didnt realise there have been so many changes but its all still been an improvement on the original btc ... but i still feel this is official chain split plus a whole new update to bitcoin as there is segwitx2 now built into it .. so i still feel bitcoin from 1st august is not bitcoin ... its a suped up altcoin with bitcoins name ...

Congratulations @ashreid1983! You received a personal award!

Happy Birthday! - You are on the Steem blockchain for 2 years!

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:

New japanese speaking community Steem Meetup badge
Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!