You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: So I encountered an Anarcho-Communist and this is my discussion/debate invitation...

in #anarchy8 years ago

Thanks for your feedback @lukestokes is always welcome. I am not sure why my posts don't do too well, but honestly I've stopped worrying whether they do well or not. Living by what I've told other people "If it happens, it happens." If I make anything at all that is more than I get from posting similar things on reddit. Our community is not toxic like that place can be at times. Perhaps adding the money incentive might help keep people a little more civil, I hadn't considered that but it just might help.

I don't rule out anything anyone says (including an-commies) I simply know too little about that topic at the moment. I don't see how you can accomplish the things proposed by communism without some group or central planning of some sort, and I really see that no different than a state. It is a group that ultimately dictates how the rest of the people live. The group may be GREAT people and often when something first starts they are. In my other post I referenced I explained what I think causes problems with GROUPS and ORGANIZATIONS over time even if they started out as great ideas. I think MANY ideas people come up with for governance could work and they are for good intentions but they are all highly susceptible to the same thing and I have yet to see a case where given time that thing does not occur.